About Ally Kelley
Ally, a fifth-generation Floridian, was born and raised in St. Petersburg, Florida. After graduating from the University of South Florida, she relocated to the Florida Keys in 2016, where she obtained her real estate license. Quickly establishing herself in the industry, Ally became one of the top-producing agents and was honored as the "Rookie of the Year" by the Marathon and Lower Keys Association of Realtors in 2017. Since then, she has successfully facilitated over $60 million in sales, including the distinction of selling Big Pine Key's highest property twice. Her accolades include being named Ocean Sotheby's "Female Top Producer," serving as President of the MLKAR in 2022, and holding various leadership roles including President-Elect (2021), Treasurer (2019-2020), and Board Member (2017-2018). In 2021, she was recognized as Marathon's "Best Realtor."
Outside of her professional achievements, Ally is passionate about her two goldendoodles, fitness, boating, and enjoying sunsets. She is actively engaged in the Middle Keys community, participating as a member of the Marathon Chamber of Commerce, the Rotary Club of Marathon, Leadership Monroe Class XXVIII, and the Baptist Health Fisherman's Foundation Board.
Ally approaches her work with the belief that luxury is defined by the experience rather than a mere price point. Her mission is to provide a "white glove experience" and exceptional results for every client, all while demonstrating her deep commitment to the Florida Keys community and her extensive knowledge of the real estate market.
Current Property Listings
Ally Kelley currently has 8 properties available in Marathon and surrounding areas.
$979,000
Listed 2025-06-06
437 Pirates Rd
Little Torch, FL33042
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,296
Lot: 6,000 sf
View Full Details
$815,000
Listed 2025-05-06
110 Santa Barbara
Marathon, FL33050
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,320
Lot: 7,200 sf
View Full Details
$749,000
Listed 2025-08-12
6104 Gulf of Mexico Blvd Unit 104
Marathon, FL33050
Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,602
Lot: 740,520 sf
View Full Details
$699,000
Listed 2025-02-21
501 E Ocean Dr Unit 17
Key Colony, FL33051
Beds: 2
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,008
Lot: sf
View Full Details
$650,000
Listed 2025-06-10
1615 Harbor Dr
Marathon, FL33050
Beds: 2
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 954
Lot: 14,810 sf
View Full Details
$6,450,000
Listed 2025-06-06
3742 Seagrape St
Big Pine Key, FL33043
Beds: 3
Baths: 3
Sq Ft: 4,687
Lot: 49,658 sf
View Full Details
$549,000
Listed 2025-09-07
320 24th Street Ocean
Marathon, FL33050
Beds: 3
Baths: 3
Sq Ft: 1,488
Lot: 827 sf
View Full Details
$529,000
Listed 2025-01-09
1115 Sombrero Blvd Unit 101A
Marathon, FL33050
Beds: 2
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,096
Lot: sf
View Full Details
$385,000
Listed 2024-12-16
1101 W Ocean Dr Unit 23
Key Colony, FL33051
Beds: 2
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 990
Lot: sf
View Full Details
$3,795,000
Listed 2025-04-26
172 Venetian Dr
Islamorada, FL33036
Beds: 5
Baths: 6
Sq Ft: 4,131
Lot: 7,000 sf
View Full Details