```
Amy Tuczynski Caniglia

Amy Tuczynski Caniglia
Real Estate Agent (Responsible Broker (Employing))
Alma CO

Responsible Broker (Employing) (CO: 40016488)

27 years experience

REALTOR® 15 Active Listings Serves Park County, CO
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Caniglia Real Estate Group Llc

Office Website
Office Address
Po Box 477
Alma, CO  80420
(Park County)
Office Phone
719-836-2766
Office Fax
Mobile
719-836-2766
Email
a**@*************.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Alma: CO Fairplay: CO Breckenridge: CO Frisco: CO Blue River: CO Jefferson: CO Como: CO Hartsel: CO

About Amy Caniglia

In 1994, Amy relocated from Upstate New York to Colorado, armed with a Bachelor of Science in Marketing and Business Management. After spending five years in the Vail Valley, she established her residence in Park County.

Amy embarked on her real estate career in 1999 and went on to establish the Caniglia Real Estate Group in 2005, concentrating her efforts on the greater Alma and Fairplay regions. Now, with nearly two decades of experience, she is recognized for her integrity, expertise, and deep understanding of the local real estate market.

Park County, CO Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$674,940
Avg. Listing Price
From Amy's portfolio
2.9 / 2.3
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
1,986 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
324
Active Listings
Current inventory

Park County, Colorado represents one of the state's most unique real estate markets, where high-altitude mountain living meets diverse property opportunities across nearly 2,200 square miles of spectacular terrain. With 37 actively licensed real estate agents serving this expansive region, the market maintains an intimate, relationship-driven character that contrasts sharply with Colorado's bustling Front Range metros. What makes this market particularly intriguing is how these same 37 agents—all reachable via email—navigate everything from historic mining town properties to luxury mountain retreats, creating a specialized expertise that's essential for anyone looking to buy, sell, or invest in this remarkable high-country region.

The relatively small number of active agents reflects both the county's rural nature and the specialized knowledge required to succeed here, where elevation changes, seasonal access challenges, and diverse property types from working ranches to vacation cabins demand deep local expertise. This tight-knit professional community means agents often collaborate rather than compete, sharing market intelligence about everything from water rights to snow load requirements that can make or break a mountain property transaction.

Major Park County, Colorado Real Estate Markets

Fairplay serves as the county seat and primary market hub, sitting at 10,578 feet elevation and offering a mix of historic properties and newer mountain homes that attract both full-time residents and recreational buyers. The town's authentic mining heritage, combined with its proximity to world-class skiing and hiking, creates a unique market dynamic where century-old cabins sell alongside modern mountain estates. Meanwhile, Alma holds the distinction of being America's highest incorporated municipality at 10,578 feet, where the real estate market focuses heavily on seasonal properties and recreational land, with buyers often seeking that authentic high-country Colorado experience.

The South Park region encompasses much of the county's ranch and agricultural properties, where large acreage parcels and working ranches create an entirely different market segment that requires specialized knowledge of water rights, grazing permits, and agricultural zoning. Smaller communities like Como and Jefferson round out the market landscape, offering everything from affordable fixer-uppers to pristine wilderness retreats, each with their own seasonal access considerations and infrastructure challenges that only experienced local agents truly understand.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Park County's real estate market operates on seasonal rhythms unlike most Colorado markets, with winter access limitations affecting both showing schedules and closing timelines in ways that can surprise newcomers to the area. The county's extreme elevation range—from around 8,500 feet to over 14,000 feet—creates microclimates and access challenges that significantly impact property values and marketability, making local agent expertise absolutely crucial for successful transactions.

Perhaps most surprisingly, the market shows remarkable resilience despite its rural nature, with properties often appreciating steadily due to limited inventory and growing demand for authentic mountain living experiences. The seasonal rental market adds another layer of complexity, as many properties serve dual purposes as personal retreats and income-generating vacation rentals, requiring agents to understand both residential and hospitality market dynamics.

Why Businesses Need Park County, Colorado Agent Contact Data

For real estate technology companies, mortgage lenders, and property service providers, having direct email access to all 37 active Park County agents represents a complete market penetration opportunity that's rare in larger markets. These agents handle everything from $50,000 mining claims to multi-million dollar ranch properties, creating diverse business opportunities for companies offering specialized services like land surveys, septic inspections, or mountain property insurance.

The tight-knit nature of Park County's real estate community means that successful business relationships here often lead to referrals throughout Colorado's mountain counties, making these 37 agent contacts a potential gateway to the broader high-country real estate market. Additionally, because these agents deal with unique challenges like extreme weather, seasonal access, and specialized mountain property issues, they represent an ideal testing ground for new products and services designed for challenging mountain markets.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Amy Caniglia has 15 properties for sale in Alma and surrounding areas. These are the top 10 listings.

$109,000

Listed 2025-01-20

Tbd Oahu Rd
Buena Vista, CO  81211

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 178,160 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$109,000

Listed 2025-01-16

Oahu Rd Lot 66
Buena Vista, CO  81211

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 178,160 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$129,900

Listed 2025-10-11

112 Sunshine Dr
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 121,532 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$698,900

Listed 2025-10-22

3415 Redhill Rd
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,630
Lot: 130,680 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$624,500

Listed 2025-10-12

133 Foxtail Ct
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 3.0
Sq Ft: 2,044
Lot: 87,120 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$79,900

Listed 2025-09-26

245 El Lobo Ln
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 45,302 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$677,000

Listed 2025-12-09

43 Clover Ct
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,564
Lot: 217,800 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$935,000

Listed 2025-12-12

228 Glacier Ridge Rd
Alma, CO  80420

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,920
Lot: 130,680 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$240,000

Listed 2024-05-30

2216 Valley of the Sun Dr
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 317,117 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$88,000

Listed 2024-07-03

250 Ski Doo Rd Lot 15
Fairplay, CO  80440

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 46,609 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Amy Caniglia currently has no rental properties available in Alma and surrounding areas. Check back later.