```
Bethany Wager-McKee

Bethany Wager-McKee
Real Estate Agent (Corporate Broker)
Marlboro NY

Corporate Broker (NY: 31OD0899518)

27 years experience

REALTOR® 3 Active Listings Serves Ulster County, NY
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Agnes I Wager Realty Inc
Office Address
25 Arapaho Dr
Marlboro, NY  12542
(Ulster County)
Office Phone
845-464-9933
Office Fax
Mobile
845-464-9933
Email
aiwa***@***.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Plattekill: NY Clintondale: NY Highland: NY Marlborough: NY Esopus: NY Milton: NY Marlboro: NY Fairview: NY Poughkeepsie: NY Haviland: NY Spackenkill: NY Arlington: NY Crown Heights: NY Hyde Park: NY Titusville: NY Freedom Plains: NY Lagrange: NY Red Oaks Mill: NY

About Bethany Wager-McKee

Agnes I. Wager Realty holds the distinction of being the first real estate office in Dutchess County, NY, solely owned by a female broker. Founded by Agnes (Aggie) Wager in 1957, the firm has a rich history that includes fond memories of the bustling office environment, which inspired many, including the current owner.

In 1995, she earned her first real estate license in Washington State. Shortly thereafter, she returned to the Hudson Valley and obtained her broker's license within a year. By 1999, she had incorporated Agnes I. Wager Realty and has been at the helm ever since.

Throughout her real estate career, she has dedicated herself to assisting clients in purchasing their first homes and guiding them as they progress through the real estate market. Her passion lies in helping individuals achieve their homeownership dreams.

In addition to her real estate work, she served as president of an appraisal company, The Appraisal Source. During the late 1990s and early 2000s, she expanded her expertise by working as a loan officer for American Home Mortgage and later for Guaranteed Home Mortgage. This diverse background equips her with a comprehensive understanding of the entire real estate transaction process.

Outside of her professional life, she is a devoted mother of five boys and a recent grandmother. Her interests include volunteering at various animal shelters, performing as a singer in a rock band with her husband, and her deep passion for horses. As both a listing and buyer’s agent, she is committed to ensuring a positive and stress-free real estate experience for her clients. She looks forward to the opportunity to assist you.

Ulster County, NY Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$782,628
Avg. Listing Price
From Bethany's portfolio
3.3 / 2.5
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
6,080 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
695
Active Listings
Current inventory

Ulster County's real estate market represents one of the Hudson Valley's most dynamic and sought-after regions, stretching from the historic city of Kingston to the artistic enclave of Woodstock and the mountain communities of the Catskills. This diverse county has experienced remarkable growth as remote work trends and urban exodus patterns have driven unprecedented demand for properties ranging from Victorian homes along the Hudson River to rustic retreats in the Shawangunk Mountains.

With 823 total actively licensed agents serving the market, Ulster County maintains a robust professional infrastructure that reflects both its population density and the complexity of its varied submarkets. Remarkably, all 823 agents maintain email connectivity, indicating a tech-savvy professional community well-equipped to handle the digital demands of modern real estate transactions in this increasingly competitive marketplace.

Major Ulster County, New York Real Estate Markets

Kingston anchors the county's commercial real estate activity as the historic seat of government, featuring a revitalized waterfront district and Stockade area that attracts both residential buyers and commercial investors. New Paltz drives significant rental and investment property demand due to SUNY New Paltz, while Woodstock commands premium prices for its bohemian charm and cultural cachet. Saugerties has emerged as a particularly hot market, offering small-town appeal with easy access to both Albany and New York City via the Thruway corridor.

The western regions encompassing Phoenicia, Mount Tremper, and other Catskill communities have seen explosive growth in vacation home sales and short-term rental investments. Towns like Rosendale and High Falls represent emerging markets where buyers seek affordability while maintaining Hudson Valley authenticity, creating distinct pricing tiers that require specialized local knowledge to navigate effectively.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Ulster County's real estate landscape defies simple categorization, with waterfront properties along the Hudson commanding vastly different prices than mountain retreats just twenty miles inland. The county's proximity to New York City—roughly two hours by car or train—has created a weekend home boom that often drives local pricing beyond what traditional residents can afford, particularly in sought-after school districts like New Paltz and Kingston.

Seasonal fluctuations significantly impact market dynamics, with spring and summer months seeing intense competition for move-in-ready properties while winter presents opportunities for cash buyers and investors. The prevalence of older housing stock means many transactions involve complex renovation considerations, flood zone evaluations, and historic preservation requirements that demand agents with deep local expertise and established contractor networks.

Why Businesses Need Ulster County, New York Agent Contact Data

Mortgage lenders, home improvement contractors, and insurance companies require direct access to Ulster County's agent network to capitalize on the county's sustained transaction volume and high property values. With every licensed agent maintaining email contact information, businesses can efficiently target their services to professionals handling everything from first-time homebuyer transactions in Kingston to luxury vacation home sales in exclusive Woodstock enclaves.

Real estate technology companies, moving services, and home staging businesses particularly benefit from this comprehensive agent database, as Ulster County's geographic diversity creates numerous niche opportunities requiring specialized service providers. The county's mix of local buyers, New York City transplants, and international investors generates diverse client needs that support a wide range of ancillary business opportunities.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/13/2026, Bethany Wager-McKee has 3 properties for sale in Marlboro and surrounding areas.

$89,900

Listed 2025-12-14

717 Modena Country Clb
Gardiner, NY  12525

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 952
Mobile Map
View Full Details

$547,000

Listed 2025-12-16

38 Sands Ave
Milton, NY  12547

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,920
Lot: 54,001 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$547,000

Listed 2025-12-20

Sands Ave
Marlboro, NY  12542

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,920
Lot: 54,001 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Bethany Wager-McKee currently has no rental properties available in Marlboro and surrounding areas. Check back later.