```
Cara Sheaffer

Cara Sheaffer
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson-Standard)
Mechanicsburg PA

Salesperson-Standard (PA: RS287228)

21 years experience

REALTOR® 9 Active Listings Serves Cumberland County, PA
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Re Max 1st Advantage

Office Website
Office Address
6375 Mercury Dr
Mechanicsburg, PA  17050
(Cumberland County)
Office Phone
717-591-5555
Office Fax
Mobile
717-860-0034
Email
c***@*****************.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Entriken: PA Hesston: PA Huntingdon: PA Mill Creek: PA McConnellstown: PA Todd: PA Marklesburg: PA James Creek: PA Petersburg: PA Wood: PA Robertsdale: PA Spruce Creek: PA Warriors Mark: PA Halifax: PA Reed: PA Mapleton Depot: PA Mapleton: PA Menno: PA Chambersburg: PA Fayetteville: PA Marion: PA Quincy: PA Guilford Township: PA Guilford: PA Saint Thomas: PA Scotland: PA Amberson: PA Toboyne: PA Fannett: PA Big Cove Tannery: PA Blue Ridge Summit: PA Burnt Cabins: PA Concord: PA Doylesburg: PA Dry Run: PA Fannettsburg: PA Metal: PA Mont Alto: PA South Mountain: PA Fort Littleton: PA Peters: PA Fort Loudon: PA State Line: PA Greencastle: PA Lemasters: PA Roxbury: PA Lurgan: PA Mercersburg: PA

About Cara Sheaffer

Committed to making a meaningful impact, this agent prioritizes integrity in every aspect of their work. They take great satisfaction in guiding clients toward achieving their dreams and unlocking their potential. Adhering to the principle of treating others as they wish to be treated, they embody a client-centered approach in all interactions.

Cumberland County, PA Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$467,476
Avg. Listing Price
From Cara's portfolio
3.5 / 2.7
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,320 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
571
Active Listings
Current inventory

Cumberland County, Pennsylvania represents one of the most dynamic real estate markets in south-central Pennsylvania, anchored by its strategic position between Harrisburg and the Maryland border. With 2,032 total actively licensed agents serving the region, the county has developed a surprisingly dense network of real estate professionals relative to its population of approximately 260,000 residents. This agent concentration reflects the area's rapid growth and the complexity of serving both suburban developments around Carlisle and Mechanicsburg, as well as rural properties scattered throughout the county's diverse landscape.

What makes Cumberland County particularly intriguing is how all 2,032 agents maintain email contact information, indicating a remarkably tech-savvy professional community that has fully embraced digital communication. This universal email adoption suggests agents here are well-equipped to handle the fast-paced transactions common in markets serving both local families and military personnel from nearby Carlisle Barracks, creating unique opportunities for businesses seeking to connect with digitally engaged real estate professionals.

Major Cumberland County, Pennsylvania Real Estate Markets

The county's real estate activity centers around several distinct markets, with Carlisle serving as the county seat and primary commercial hub, while Mechanicsburg has emerged as a major suburban center attracting families seeking proximity to Harrisburg without the urban density. Camp Hill, though smaller, commands some of the highest property values in the region due to its excellent school district and convenient access to the state capital. These three municipalities alone account for a significant portion of the county's real estate transactions, supported by nearly half of the active agent population.

Beyond the major towns, Cumberland County's market extends into rural communities like Shippensburg, New Cumberland, and Wormleysburg, each presenting unique challenges that require specialized local knowledge. The diversity ranges from historic properties in established neighborhoods to new construction in rapidly developing townships like Silver Spring and Upper Allen, creating market segments that demand different expertise and professional networks among the county's extensive agent community.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Cumberland County's real estate market operates with surprising complexity, influenced by its position within the Harrisburg metropolitan statistical area while maintaining distinct rural characteristics. The presence of major employers like the U.S. Army War College, Amazon fulfillment centers, and healthcare systems creates steady demand for housing across multiple price points. Military transfers generate consistent turnover in certain segments, while the growing retiree population from nearby metropolitan areas drives demand for specific property types and locations.

The geographic spread from the Susquehanna River valley to the foothills of South Mountain creates microclimates of real estate activity that require agents to specialize in everything from riverfront properties to mountain retreats. This diversity explains why the county supports such a large number of active agents, as successful professionals often focus on specific townships or property types rather than attempting to serve the entire county market.

Why Businesses Need Cumberland County, Pennsylvania Agent Contact Data

The complete email coverage among Cumberland County's 2,032 licensed agents creates exceptional opportunities for service providers, lenders, and technology companies to reach a highly engaged professional audience. Unlike markets where agent contact information is fragmented or outdated, Cumberland County's universal email adoption means marketing campaigns and business development efforts can achieve comprehensive market penetration with confidence that messages will reach active, responsive professionals.

For businesses ranging from home inspection services to real estate software providers, having direct access to this complete agent database enables targeted outreach that can capture significant market share within a defined geographic area. The combination of market activity, professional density, and digital connectivity makes Cumberland County an ideal testing ground for new services or a reliable market for established businesses seeking to expand their client base among committed, accessible real estate professionals.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/7/2026, Cara Sheaffer has 9 properties for sale in Mechanicsburg and surrounding areas.

$33,900

Listed 2025-12-12

6148 Nugget Way
Saint Thomas, PA  17252

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,064
Mobile Map
View Full Details

$39,900

Listed 2025-05-20

12277 Loop Rd
Fayetteville, PA  17222

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 20,909 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$70,000

Listed 2025-07-20

1685 Liberty Dr
Chambersburg, PA  17202

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,344
Mobile Map
View Full Details

$274,900

Listed 2025-12-14

2419 McCleary Dr
Chambersburg, PA  17201

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,206
Lot: 11,326 sf
Townhomes Map
View Full Details

$242,900

Listed 2026-01-28

1660 Hawthorne Ln
Chambersburg, PA  17202

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 1,008
Lot: 22,216 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$349,900

Listed 2025-12-05

1565 Fox Hollow Rd
Shermans Dale, PA  17090

Beds: 5.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 2,978
Lot: 65,340 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$389,900

Listed 2025-11-23

112 Milky Way
Shippensburg, PA  17257

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,861
Lot: 10,454 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$264,900

Listed 2025-12-14

11400 Nicole Dr
Greencastle, PA  17225

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,275
Lot: 7,841 sf
Townhomes Map
View Full Details

$79,900

Listed 2025-12-05

Stumpy Ln
Fort Loudon, PA  17224

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 270,943 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Cara Sheaffer currently has no rental properties available in Mechanicsburg and surrounding areas. Check back later.