```
Carol Tomayko

Carol Tomayko
Real Estate Agent (Associate Broker (AB)-Standard)
Zelienople PA

Associate Broker (AB)-Standard (PA: AB066255)

REALTOR® 5 Active Listings Serves Butler County, PA
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Howard Hanna - Cranberry

Office Website
Office Address
22420 Perry Hwy
Zelienople, PA  16063
(Butler County)
Office Phone
724-452-1100
Office Fax
Mobile
412-519-2946
Email
caro*********@*****.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Harmony Township: PA Economy: PA Baden: PA Hampton Twp: PA Franklin Park: PA Wexford: PA McCandless Township: PA Ingomar: PA Ross Township: PA McKnight: PA Emsworth: PA Glenshaw: PA Meridian: PA Unionville: PA Butler: PA Oak Hills: PA Meadowood: PA East Butler: PA Shanor-Northvue: PA Homeacre-Lyndora: PA Herman: PA Nixon: PA Callery: PA Connoquenessing: PA Evans City: PA Harmony: PA Seven Fields: PA Mars: PA Branchton: PA Slippery Rock University: PA West Liberty: PA Slippery Rock: PA Zelienople: PA Cranberry Township: PA Fox Run: PA Koppel: PA Ellwood City: PA Ellport: PA Fombell: PA Pittsburgh: PA

About Carol Tomayko

**Carol Tomayko: Dedicated Real Estate Professional**

Carol Tomayko is a seasoned real estate agent specializing in Butler, Beaver, Allegheny, and Lawrence Counties. With a commitment to exceptional service and professionalism, she prioritizes her clients' needs above all else.

**Professional Credentials:**
- Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR)
- Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS)
- Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) designation
- Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES)
- Ranked among the top 1% of sales associates nationwide

Under her leadership, the Carol Tomayko Team has been recognized as one of Pennsylvania's top-performing teams, as noted in the Real Trends America's Best Real Estate Agents list in collaboration with The Zillow Group. Additionally, they have been featured in the Pittsburgh Business Times' "Who's Who in Residential Real Estate" and consistently rank among the top 25 teams in the Western Pennsylvania RE/MAX region.

**About Carol:**
Carol’s approach to real estate is rooted in traditional values combined with modern technology. She continuously updates her knowledge of market trends, ensuring her clients receive informed guidance. As a skilled communicator and negotiator, she excels in marketing properties effectively.

Her success is largely attributed to her unwavering client-first philosophy. With approximately 80% of her business stemming from referrals by satisfied clients, Carol takes pride in the relationships she builds. Her dedication has consistently placed her among the top sales associates in the nation.

A lifelong resident of Butler County, Carol shares her life with her husband, Tom. They take pride in their family, including their married children and their spouses: Alesha and Jason, TW and Jess, Matthias and Thanya. Outside of real estate, Carol is actively involved in her local church and cherishes time spent with family and friends.

The Carol Tomayko Team is committed to delivering results with a focus on client satisfaction.

Butler County, PA Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$515,318
Avg. Listing Price
From Carol's portfolio
3.6 / 2.8
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,471 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
402
Active Listings
Current inventory

Butler County, Pennsylvania's real estate market reflects the dynamic nature of southwestern Pennsylvania's evolving economy, where traditional manufacturing communities are experiencing renewed interest from homebuyers seeking affordable alternatives to Pittsburgh's higher-priced neighborhoods. With 818 total actively licensed agents serving the county, this market demonstrates robust professional representation that facilitates transactions across diverse property types, from historic downtown storefronts in Butler city to sprawling suburban developments in Cranberry Township.

The county's strategic location along major transportation corridors, including Interstate 79 and Route 8, has transformed formerly rural areas into desirable residential communities. All 818 agents maintain email contact information, indicating a tech-savvy professional network that leverages digital communication to serve clients across Butler County's varied landscape, from the Ohio River communities in the west to the rural townships bordering Armstrong County in the east.

Major Butler County, Pennsylvania Real Estate Markets

Cranberry Township stands as Butler County's crown jewel for residential development, featuring master-planned communities and executive housing that attracts Pittsburgh commuters willing to drive for larger lots and newer construction. The township's proximity to major employers like Westinghouse Electric Company has created a stable buyer pool seeking move-up properties. Meanwhile, Butler city's historic downtown district is experiencing revitalization as young professionals discover restored Victorian homes and converted loft spaces at fraction of urban Pittsburgh prices.

The southern tier communities of Mars, Evans City, and Zelienople form a interconnected market where buyers often cross municipal boundaries during their home search, creating opportunities for agents who understand regional pricing variations. Northern communities like Slippery Rock benefit from university-driven rental demand, while western areas near Beaver County attract buyers seeking rural acreage with reasonable commuting distance to both Pittsburgh and smaller regional employment centers.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Butler County's real estate market operates on multiple price tiers that can shift dramatically within short distances, creating challenges for buyers unfamiliar with local market conditions. Properties in Cranberry Township's sought-after subdivisions command premium prices, while comparable homes in nearby Penn Township or Clinton Township offer significant savings despite similar school districts and amenities. This geographic pricing complexity requires agents with intimate knowledge of municipal boundaries, school catchment areas, and development patterns.

Seasonal market patterns in Butler County reflect both traditional spring selling seasons and unique local factors, including agricultural property transactions that peak during fall months and recreational property sales near Moraine and Raccoon Creek state parks. The county's mix of new construction in growth areas and older housing stock in established communities creates diverse inventory cycles that experienced agents navigate by understanding both builder release schedules and estate sale patterns in mature neighborhoods.

Why Businesses Need Butler County, Pennsylvania Agent Contact Data

Mortgage lenders, home improvement contractors, and property insurance providers recognize that Butler County's 818 licensed agents represent direct access to active homebuyers and sellers across varied price points and property types. Companies offering services from luxury kitchen renovations in Cranberry Township to septic system maintenance in rural townships benefit from targeted outreach to agents who specialize in specific geographic areas or client demographics within the county's diverse market segments.

Title companies, moving services, and home inspection businesses find Butler County agent networks particularly valuable because of the county's position as a destination market for Pittsburgh-area relocations, creating consistent demand for comprehensive real estate service providers. The universal email accessibility among all 818 agents enables efficient communication for time-sensitive opportunities, property listings, and market updates that drive business relationships in this professionally active market.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/13/2026, Carol Tomayko has 5 properties for sale in Zelienople and surrounding areas.

$485,000

Listed 2025-07-05

808 Glendale Ct # 16-66
Cranberry Township, PA  16066

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft:
Lot: 9,670 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$285,000

Listed 2025-12-12

212 Pine St
Zelienople, PA  16063

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft:
Lot: 4,792 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$285,000

Listed 2026-01-22

46 Marion Dr
Zelienople, PA  16063

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.5
Sq Ft: 1,078
Lot: 16,553 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$525,000

Listed 2025-09-18

517 Blake Dr
Zelienople, PA  16063

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft:
Lot: 7,841 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$399,500

Listed 2025-08-06

100 Joshua Dr
Harmony, PA  16037

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 2,264
Lot: 110,337 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Carol Tomayko currently has no rental properties available in Zelienople and surrounding areas. Check back later.