Carol Tomayko

Carol Tomayko
Real Estate Agent (Associate Broker (AB)-Standard)
Zelienople PA

Associate Broker (AB)-Standard (PA: AB066255)

REALTOR® 3 Active Listings Serves Butler County, PA
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Howard Hanna - Cranberry

Office Website
Office Address
22420 Perry Hwy
Zelienople, PA  16063
(Butler County)
Office Phone
724-452-1100
Office Fax
Mobile
724-452-1100
Email
carol.tomayko@gmail.com

Service Areas

Harmony Township: PA Economy: PA Baden: PA Hampton Twp: PA Franklin Park: PA Wexford: PA McCandless Township: PA Ingomar: PA Ross Township: PA McKnight: PA Emsworth: PA Glenshaw: PA Meridian: PA Unionville: PA Butler: PA Oak Hills: PA Meadowood: PA East Butler: PA Shanor-Northvue: PA Homeacre-Lyndora: PA Herman: PA Nixon: PA Callery: PA Connoquenessing: PA Evans City: PA Harmony: PA Seven Fields: PA Mars: PA Branchton: PA Slippery Rock University: PA West Liberty: PA Slippery Rock: PA Zelienople: PA Cranberry Township: PA Fox Run: PA Koppel: PA Ellwood City: PA Ellport: PA Fombell: PA Pittsburgh: PA

About Carol Tomayko

**Carol Tomayko: Dedicated Real Estate Professional**

Carol Tomayko is a seasoned real estate agent specializing in Butler, Beaver, Allegheny, and Lawrence Counties. With a commitment to exceptional service and professionalism, she prioritizes her clients' needs above all else.

**Professional Credentials:**
- Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR)
- Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS)
- Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) designation
- Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES)
- Ranked among the top 1% of sales associates nationwide

Under her leadership, the Carol Tomayko Team has been recognized as one of Pennsylvania's top-performing teams, as noted in the Real Trends America's Best Real Estate Agents list in collaboration with The Zillow Group. Additionally, they have been featured in the Pittsburgh Business Times' "Who's Who in Residential Real Estate" and consistently rank among the top 25 teams in the Western Pennsylvania RE/MAX region.

**About Carol:**
Carol’s approach to real estate is rooted in traditional values combined with modern technology. She continuously updates her knowledge of market trends, ensuring her clients receive informed guidance. As a skilled communicator and negotiator, she excels in marketing properties effectively.

Her success is largely attributed to her unwavering client-first philosophy. With approximately 80% of her business stemming from referrals by satisfied clients, Carol takes pride in the relationships she builds. Her dedication has consistently placed her among the top sales associates in the nation.

A lifelong resident of Butler County, Carol shares her life with her husband, Tom. They take pride in their family, including their married children and their spouses: Alesha and Jason, TW and Jess, Matthias and Thanya. Outside of real estate, Carol is actively involved in her local church and cherishes time spent with family and friends.

The Carol Tomayko Team is committed to delivering results with a focus on client satisfaction.

Butler County, PA Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$546,717
Avg. Listing Price
From Carol's portfolio
3.6 / 2.9
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,446 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
445
Active Listings
Current inventory

If you need to reach working real estate agents in Butler County, Pennsylvania, this list was built for you. Mortgage lenders prospecting for referral partners, title companies building closing pipelines, PropTech platforms launching in new markets, continuing education providers filling course seats, insurance agents targeting E&O buyers, and recruiters hunting productive agents all rely on verified contact data like this to drive outreach that actually lands.

When you buy Butler County real estate agent email list data from Dr Bill, you get {{AGENT_COUNT}} actively licensed agents with verified email addresses, plus {{CELL_COUNT}} agents who also have cell phone numbers on file. That combination makes multi-channel campaigns possible without needing to stitch together data from three different vendors. One clean file, ready to deploy in cold-email platforms like Zap Contact (zapcontact.com) or any CRM you already use.

Why Buy a Butler County Real Estate Agent Email List From Dr Bill

This data is sourced directly from Pennsylvania state licensing boards, which means every contact is an actively licensed agent, not someone who let their license lapse two years ago. New emails are added weekly, the full list is cleaned monthly, and the entire database is refreshed bi-annually. That maintenance cycle is why Dr Bill can back the data with a 96% deliverability guarantee — a standard that cheap scraped lists pulled from Zillow profiles simply cannot match.

Since 2005, Dr Bill has sold over 31,000 lists to B2B marketers, recruiters, and service providers across every sector that touches real estate. The difference between a vendor that guarantees deliverability and one that just hands you a CSV and disappears becomes obvious the first time a campaign bounces at 30 percent. Verified sourcing and a real maintenance schedule are what separate professional-grade data from filler.

How to Use This Butler County Agent List

The most immediate use case is cold email outreach, and the file is formatted to drop directly into platforms like Zap Contact (zapcontact.com) without reformatting. Beyond email, the same data supports direct mail campaigns, phone outreach using the included cell numbers, and LinkedIn audience matching to run parallel ad sequences to the same contacts. Each of those channels reinforces the others when you are working the same prospect list across multiple touchpoints.

The file also lets you segment by broker versus individual sales agent, which matters when your offer is relevant to one group and not the other. Office managers at brokerages respond to different pitches than solo agents grinding transactions. Filtering before you send keeps your deliverability score clean and your messaging targeted.

Why Butler County, Pennsylvania Agent Data Matters

Butler County covers a distinct market anchored by cities including Butler, Cranberry Township, Mars, Zelienople, and Saxonburg. The {{AGENT_COUNT}} licensed agents working this county are embedded in local transaction networks that a generic statewide Pennsylvania blast will never reach efficiently. Targeting Butler County specifically means your message arrives as locally relevant, not as another mass broadcast from someone who does not know the market.

No other vendor offers this data segmented to the zip code level within Butler County. That granularity lets you focus spend on the specific corridors where your business operates rather than paying for agent contacts two counties away. The list is available at the state, county, city, or zip code level, giving you the exact footprint your campaign requires.

Current Property Listings

As of 6/27/2026, Carol Tomayko has 3 properties for sale in Zelienople and surrounding areas.

$335,000

Listed 2026-05-08

107 White Fox Ct
Ellwood City, PA  16117

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,322
Lot: 3,136 sf
Condo Map
View Full Details

$485,000

Listed 2025-07-05

808 Glendale Ct # 16-66
Cranberry Township, PA  16066

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 0
Lot: 9,670 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$385,000

Listed 2026-05-22

516 Florida Blvd
Cranberry Township, PA  16066

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,000
Lot: 2,047 sf
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Carol Tomayko currently has no rental properties available in Zelienople and surrounding areas. Check back later.