```
Catherine A Rustin

Catherine A Rustin
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Sarasota FL

Salesperson (FL: 3332179)

28 years experience

REALTOR® 2 Active Listings Serves Sarasota County, FL
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
First Light Real Estate

Office Website
Office Address
1990 Main St Ste 750
Sarasota, FL  34236
(Sarasota County)
Office Phone
941-650-2256
Office Fax
Mobile
941-650-2256
Email
cath*@*****************.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

South Sarasota: FL South Gate Ridge: FL Vamo: FL Ridge Wood Heights: FL Gulf Gate Estates: FL Sarasota Springs: FL Bee Ridge: FL Sarasota: FL Southgate: FL Siesta Key: FL North Sarasota: FL Whitfield: FL Tallevast: FL Fruitville: FL Lake Sarasota: FL Osprey: FL Nokomis: FL Laurel: FL Venice: FL North Venice: FL South Venice: FL Braden River: FL Longboat Key: FL Bradenton: FL

About Catherine Rustin

Cathy Rustin has called Sarasota, Florida, home since 2002, and her deep-rooted connection to the area enhances her commitment to guiding clients in maximizing the region's abundant offerings, including its beautiful beaches, boating opportunities, fine dining, shopping, and eco-adventures. In 2022, she established First Light Real Estate after achieving remarkable success at her previous brokerage, where she consistently ranked among the top 2% of agents and earned prestigious accolades such as the Hall of Fame and Titan Club awards.

As a Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist and a member of the Institute for Luxury Home Marketing’s Million Dollar Guild, Cathy possesses extensive expertise in Gulf Coast luxury real estate. She is also a Residential Construction Certified agent, further solidifying her status as a knowledgeable resource in the market. Currently, she ranks in the top 5% of Realtors in Sarasota County.

Cathy understands that the home buying and selling processes involve numerous considerations, and she adopts a personalized, hands-on approach to ensure her clients experience a seamless and stress-free journey. Having purchased her first home at the age of 22 and subsequently built two luxury residences—one in Isleworth, Windermere, and another on the waterfront in Sarasota—she has firsthand experience across a spectrum of property types. This diverse background allows her to appreciate the unique qualities of residential real estate at all price points. While she specializes in luxury properties, Cathy is dedicated to serving a wide range of clients with varying objectives.

Sarasota County, FL Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$948,330
Avg. Listing Price
From Catherine's portfolio
3.1 / 2.6
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,142 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
6180
Active Listings
Current inventory

Sarasota County's real estate market stands as one of Florida's most sophisticated and competitive landscapes, with an impressive network of 13,714 actively licensed agents serving this coveted Gulf Coast region. This substantial agent presence reflects the area's magnetic appeal to both seasonal residents and permanent transplants seeking the perfect blend of cultural sophistication and coastal living.

The market's complexity stems from its diverse property types, ranging from luxury waterfront estates in exclusive enclaves to family-friendly neighborhoods inland. With all 13,714 agents maintaining current email addresses, the communication infrastructure supporting this market demonstrates the high level of professionalism and connectivity that defines Sarasota County's real estate ecosystem.

Major Sarasota County, Florida Real Estate Markets

Sarasota city anchors the county's luxury market, with downtown condominiums and bayfront properties commanding premium prices, while nearby Siesta Key continues to attract international buyers drawn to its world-renowned beaches. Venice offers a unique blend of historic charm and modern development, particularly appealing to retirees, while North Port has emerged as a surprising hotspot for younger families seeking affordability without sacrificing amenities.

The barrier islands, including Longboat Key and Casey Key, represent some of Florida's most exclusive real estate, creating specialized market segments that require deep local expertise. Osprey and Nokomis round out the county's diverse offerings, providing everything from golf course communities to waterfront living at various price points, each demanding agents with specific neighborhood knowledge and client relationships.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Sarasota County's real estate market operates on multiple tiers simultaneously, with luxury properties often selling through private networks while entry-level homes face intense competition from cash buyers and investors. The seasonal nature of the market creates unique timing challenges, with peak activity running from January through April when northern buyers actively search, followed by a strategic summer period when locals and year-round residents dominate transactions.

Geographic micro-markets within the county can vary dramatically in pricing, inventory levels, and buyer demographics, sometimes within just a few miles of each other. This complexity requires agents to maintain hyperlocal expertise while understanding broader county trends, creating opportunities for businesses that can effectively segment and target specific agent specialties and territorial focuses.

Why Businesses Need Sarasota County, Florida Agent Contact Data

Mortgage lenders, title companies, and home service providers require direct access to Sarasota County's extensive agent network to capitalize on the area's robust transaction volume and high property values. With such a large concentration of active agents, businesses can develop targeted campaigns for specific market segments, whether focusing on luxury specialists, first-time buyer experts, or investment property professionals.

The complete email accessibility of all 13,714 agents creates unprecedented opportunities for B2B marketing, continuing education providers, and real estate technology companies to reach this influential market efficiently. Given Sarasota County's reputation as a trendsetting market that often influences broader Florida real estate patterns, establishing strong relationships with local agents can provide valuable market intelligence and expansion opportunities throughout the region.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Catherine Rustin has 2 properties for sale in Sarasota and surrounding areas.

$568,000

Listed 2026-02-13

1484 Dorgali Dr
Sarasota, FL  34238

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,764
Lot: 6,534 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$719,000

Listed 2026-01-23

242 Hidden Bay Dr Unit 602
Osprey, FL  34229

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,932
Condos Map
View Full Details

$789,000

Listed 2025-05-02

260 Hidden Bay Dr Unit 305
Osprey, FL  34229

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,168
Lot: 46,174 sf
Condos Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Catherine Rustin currently has no rental properties available in Sarasota and surrounding areas. Check back later.