(SD: )
Custer County, South Dakota represents one of the state's most unique real estate markets, where rugged Black Hills terrain meets surprising residential demand. With just 7 actively licensed real estate agents serving the entire county, this market operates with an intimacy rarely seen in modern real estate, where every professional knows their competition personally and market dynamics shift based on individual agent activity.
The scarcity of agents in Custer County creates an interesting paradox - while buyers and sellers have limited representation options, the 7 licensed professionals maintain remarkably high connectivity, with all agents equipped with email addresses for digital communication. This small but technologically equipped agent pool handles everything from rustic cabin sales near Crazy Horse Memorial to residential properties in Custer city proper.
Custer serves as the county's primary real estate hub, anchoring most residential and commercial transactions with its historic downtown and proximity to major tourist attractions. The city's real estate market benefits enormously from its position as a gateway to both Custer State Park and the broader Black Hills region, creating consistent demand for both permanent residences and investment properties catering to tourism.
Beyond Custer city, the county's real estate landscape includes unique markets in Hermosa and various unincorporated communities scattered throughout the Black Hills foothills. These smaller markets often feature larger acreage properties, hunting lodges, and recreational cabins that appeal to out-of-state buyers seeking Black Hills retreats, creating pricing dynamics that can vary dramatically based on proximity to natural attractions and accessibility during winter months.
Custer County's real estate market exhibits seasonal fluctuations tied directly to tourism patterns, with spring and summer months generating the majority of showing activity and property sales. The challenging winter weather and remote locations of many properties create a compressed selling season, forcing the county's 7 agents to maximize productivity during peak months while maintaining client relationships through slower winter periods.
Geographic complexity adds another layer to market dynamics, as properties can range from in-town Custer lots to remote mountain parcels requiring four-wheel drive access. This diversity means agents must possess expertise spanning traditional residential sales, recreational property marketing, and rural land transactions, making each of the county's few licensed professionals particularly versatile compared to urban specialists.
For businesses targeting Custer County's real estate market, having direct contact information for all 7 licensed agents provides access to virtually the entire professional network in one comprehensive dataset. Mortgage lenders, home inspectors, insurance providers, and construction companies can reach the complete agent population efficiently, ensuring no potential referral sources or partnership opportunities are overlooked in this concentrated market.
The complete email accessibility of Custer County's agent roster makes digital marketing campaigns particularly effective, allowing service providers to achieve nearly 100% market penetration with targeted communications. Given the seasonal nature of the local market and the geographic challenges agents face, businesses offering time-sensitive services or remote capabilities can position themselves as valuable resources for the county's small but active real estate community.
As of 2/17/2026, Craig Reindl has 11 properties for sale in Custer and surrounding areas. These are the top 10 listings.
$263,900
Listed 2025-10-15
$849,000
Listed 2025-03-19
$149,000
Listed 2024-10-21
$411,400
Listed 2025-06-17
$982,350
Listed 2025-06-17
$369,000
Listed 2025-10-10
$2,255,875
Listed 2025-09-10
$1,285,000
Listed 2025-09-02
$639,900
Listed 2025-10-03
$599,000
Listed 2026-01-08
Craig Reindl currently has no rental properties available in Custer and surrounding areas. Check back later.