```
Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin
Real Estate Agent (Principal Broker)
Lancaster OH

Principal Broker (OH: 2024003983)

10 years experience

REALTOR® 3 Active Listings Serves Fairfield County, OH
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Key Realty

Office Website
Office Address
237 Seneca Dr
Lancaster, OH  43130
(Fairfield County)
Office Phone
740-277-1647
Office Fax
Mobile
740-974-4190
Email
j**@******************.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Lancaster: OH

About Jay Mattlin

**Real Estate Agent Bio**

This real estate agent prioritizes transparency and effective communication, addressing common concerns that clients often have. With a commitment to responsiveness, they ensure that all calls and emails are returned promptly, typically within one business day. Recognizing that timely communication is a significant frustration for many, this agent strives to alleviate that issue.

While experiences with real estate professionals can vary, this agent is known for their honesty and approachability. They take pride in fostering a friendly atmosphere and are dedicated to supporting their clients' real estate aspirations. Loyalty to family, friends, and clients is a fundamental value, and they are always ready to advocate for those they care about.

In terms of expertise, this agent specializes in several areas, including:

- Assisting first-time homebuyers
- Guiding first-time sellers
- Navigating USDA and FHA loans
- Managing investment and rental properties
- Overseeing property management and tenant relations

Even if your specific needs are not listed, this agent encourages potential clients to reach out. If they cannot assist, they will gladly refer you to a qualified colleague.

Beyond real estate, this agent enjoys personal pursuits such as winemaking, particularly crafting a notable pomegranate Zinfandel, as well as kayaking and hiking. They are also deeply committed to community service, recognizing the importance of culture and community well-being.

Professionally, this agent has honed several key skills:

- **Active Listening:** Acknowledging the importance of truly hearing clients' needs.
- **Attention to Detail:** A meticulous approach ensures that nothing is overlooked.
- **Organizational Skills:** Recognizing that even minor disorganization can jeopardize transactions, they maintain a structured workflow to facilitate smooth dealings.

This agent is ready to provide the support and expertise needed to navigate the real estate landscape effectively.

Fairfield County, OH Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$417,738
Avg. Listing Price
From Jay's portfolio
3.4 / 2.5
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,183 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
484
Active Listings
Current inventory

Fairfield County, Ohio represents a dynamic real estate landscape where suburban growth meets rural charm, creating unique opportunities for both residential and commercial development. Located in central Ohio just southeast of Columbus, this market has experienced steady appreciation driven by its proximity to the state capital while maintaining its distinct small-town character across communities like Lancaster, Pickerington, and Canal Winchester.

The county's real estate professionals operate in an environment supported by 902 total actively licensed agents, with complete digital connectivity as all 902 agents maintain email addresses for modern communication. This high level of digital engagement reflects the market's adaptation to contemporary real estate practices while serving diverse property types from historic downtown Lancaster buildings to new construction in rapidly expanding suburbs.

Major Fairfield County, Ohio Real Estate Markets

Lancaster serves as the county seat and primary commercial hub, featuring a revitalized downtown district that has attracted both residential loft conversions and retail investments. The city's historic charm combined with modern amenities has created a surprising renaissance in urban-style living within a traditionally rural county. Meanwhile, Pickerington has emerged as a sought-after suburban destination, particularly for families seeking top-rated schools and easy Columbus commuting access.

The northern communities like Canal Winchester and Lithopolis benefit from their strategic position along major transportation corridors, experiencing significant residential development pressure. These areas showcase some of the county's most rapid appreciation rates, while southern regions maintain their agricultural character with larger parcels attracting buyers seeking privacy and space. Baltimore and Amanda represent emerging markets where smart investors are positioning themselves ahead of anticipated growth patterns.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Fairfield County's real estate market operates across distinctly different economic zones, from Columbus bedroom communities experiencing suburban sprawl to rural townships where agricultural land conversion drives development opportunities. This geographic diversity creates pricing variations that can surprise outsiders, with waterfront properties along Buckeye Lake commanding premium prices while rural acreage offers exceptional value propositions for various buyer segments.

The market benefits from Ohio's generally stable economic environment while experiencing growth pressures from Columbus metropolitan expansion. Inventory levels fluctuate significantly between urban Lancaster properties and rural listings, creating distinct seasonal patterns that experienced agents navigate strategically. Commercial real estate particularly thrives along US-33 and other major corridors, where distribution and light manufacturing facilities capitalize on the county's logistics advantages.

Why Businesses Need Fairfield County, Ohio Agent Contact Data

Mortgage lenders and financial services companies find Fairfield County's agent network essential for capturing both first-time homebuyers in suburban developments and experienced investors pursuing rural land opportunities. The county's 902 digitally connected agents represent direct access to deal flow across market segments that traditional advertising often misses, particularly in specialized niches like equestrian properties and agricultural transitions.

Real estate service providers, from home inspectors to title companies, rely on comprehensive agent contact databases to establish referral relationships across the county's diverse geographic markets. Insurance companies particularly benefit from agent connections given the varied property types and risk profiles, while moving companies and contractors use agent networks to identify emerging development areas where their services will be most needed.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Jay Mattlin has 3 properties for sale in Lancaster and surrounding areas.

$279,900

Listed 2025-11-06

844 E Wheeling St
Lancaster, OH  43130

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.5
Sq Ft: 1,750
Lot: 10,890 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$250,000

Listed 2025-09-11

545 W Columbus St
Pickerington, OH  43147

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 1,254
Lot: 25,700 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$50,000

Listed 2026-02-05

542 Reese Ave
Lancaster, OH  43130

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 672
Lot: 8,712 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Jay Mattlin currently has no rental properties available in Lancaster and surrounding areas. Check back later.