About Jonathan Spencer
Jonathan Spencer brings a distinctive blend of financial acumen and community engagement to the real estate sector, ensuring a comprehensive and efficient experience for his clients. With a robust partnership with Compass, he has consistently demonstrated his ability to successfully market and sell properties.
Beginning his professional journey as an investment manager, Jonathan honed his skills in client relations and strategic investments. His transition to real estate on the Monterey Peninsula has been marked by impressive achievements, including over $200 million in sales since 2014. He was recognized as Rookie of the Year in his inaugural year and has maintained his status as a top producer ever since. Notably, his $28 million sale of Canary Cottage in 2018 set a record as the highest sale in Monterey County that year and the second-highest in Pebble Beach's history. In 2021, he earned a place on the Wall Street Journal's Real Trends list of America's Best Real Estate Professionals.
Jonathan's affinity for the Monterey Peninsula is deeply rooted; he spent many childhood summers visiting his grandparents in Carmel. This connection influenced his decision to relocate there with his wife and raise their two children, whom he considers fortunate to grow up in such a picturesque environment. His passion for the area, coupled with his financial expertise, allows him to provide exceptional guidance to clients, whether facilitating a 1031 Exchange or assisting first-time homebuyers in making informed decisions.
Integrity is a cornerstone of Jonathan's professional philosophy. He has built a reputation for honesty and dependability, earning the trust of his clients. His dedication to their success is evident in his proactive efforts, including advocating for clients before the Carmel-by-the-Sea City Council. Jonathan has also established a network of reliable vendors, ensuring that his clients have access to quality resources and solutions. When he commits to a task, he follows through with precision and timeliness.
Jonathan's meticulous approach and strong work ethic were instilled in him from a young age. He achieved the rank of Eagle Scout and captained his high school baseball and football teams. His leadership skills were further developed as the Director of the 2008 Mitt Romney presidential campaign at Brigham Young University.
Sports continue to play a significant role in Jonathan's life, both as a participant and a fan. He embraces a competitive spirit but emphasizes that success is not solely about winning; it is about securing the right deal for the right home at the right time.
Currently, Jonathan remains actively involved in his community, volunteering with various organizations, including the Interfaith Homeless Emergency Lodging Program (I-HELP), Boy Scouts of America, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Tularcitos Elementary School PTO, Monterey Peninsula Ballet Theater, Salvation Army, Monterey Recreation, Carmel Youth Baseball, and the YMCA of the Monterey Peninsula.
Current Property Listings
Jonathan Spencer currently has 3 properties available in Carmel By The Sea and surrounding areas.
$9,000,000
Listed 2025-04-25
31475 Highway 1
Carmel, CA93923
Beds: 4
Baths: 6
Sq Ft: 6,923
Lot: 259,618 sf
View Full Details
$4,475,000
Listed 2025-07-12
$14,500,000
Listed 2025-05-05
31453 Highway 1
Carmel, CA93923
Beds: 5
Baths: 6
Sq Ft: 8,855
Lot: 283,140 sf
View Full Details