```
Karen Mergenthaler

Karen Mergenthaler
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Lake Placid NY

Salesperson (NY: 40ME1024952)

23 years experience

REALTOR® 3 Active Listings Serves Essex County, NY
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Merrill L Thomas Inc

Office Website
Office Address
2469 Main St
Lake Placid, NY  12946
(Essex County)
Office Phone
518-523-2519
Office Fax
Mobile
518-524-4022
Email
kare*@*****************.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Bloomingdale: NY Childwold: NY Hopkinton: NY Piercefield: NY Clare: NY Gabriels: NY Jay: NY Keene: NY Saint Huberts: NY Keene Valley: NY Newcomb: NY Santa Clara: NY Lake Clear: NY Harrietstown: NY Upper Saint Regis: NY Lake Placid: NY Paul Smiths: NY Rainbow Lake: NY Ray Brook: NY St. Regis Falls: NY Saranac Lake: NY Massawepie: NY Tupper Lake: NY Upper Jay: NY Onchiota: NY Loon Lake: NY Duane: NY Vermontville: NY Wilmington: NY Whiteface Mountain: NY

About Karen Mergenthaler

Karen possesses extensive experience in facilitating real estate transactions throughout the Lake Placid region. Renowned for her exceptional customer service, she maintains consistent communication and demonstrates meticulous attention to detail for both buyers and sellers. Her guiding principle centers on the importance of relationships, emphasizing that her work is fundamentally about the individuals she serves. Karen's passion for her profession is evident, and her clients often commend her thoughtfulness and dedication throughout the buying or selling process.

An active community member, Karen holds the position of Education Chair on the Northern Adirondack Board of Realtors. She is committed to professional development, having earned the Resort and Second Home Property Specialist (RSPS) and Green designations, and is currently pursuing her Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) designation. Recognizing the dynamic nature of the real estate industry, she values the ongoing education opportunities available in the area, which are led by knowledgeable instructors.

Consistently recognized as a top producer within the regional MLS network, Karen has achieved a career volume exceeding $80 million. Originally from Northern New Jersey, she relocated to Lake Placid in 1994 with her husband and their three children. This community has become their cherished home, and Karen finds great fulfillment in introducing others to the Adirondack lifestyle that her family has come to love.

Essex County, NY Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$807,203
Avg. Listing Price
From Karen's portfolio
3.6 / 2.4
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,217 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
258
Active Listings
Current inventory

Essex County, New York's real estate market represents one of the most unique and pristine markets in the Northeast, encompassing vast wilderness areas, historic communities, and coveted Adirondack lakefront properties. With 152 actively licensed real estate agents serving this expansive county, the market operates with a remarkably personal touch that reflects the region's close-knit character and specialized property types.

The market dynamics here differ significantly from urban centers, with agents handling everything from remote wilderness parcels and historic camps to charming village homes in communities like Elizabethtown, Keene, and Ticonderoga. What makes this market particularly fascinating is how seasonal fluctuations drive activity, with summer months bringing intense competition for lakefront properties while winter periods focus on year-round residences and investment opportunities.

Major Essex County, New York Real Estate Markets

Lake Placid stands as the crown jewel of Essex County's real estate markets, commanding premium prices for its Olympic legacy properties and year-round recreational appeal. The village and surrounding areas attract buyers seeking luxury vacation homes, investment properties, and retirement destinations. Meanwhile, communities like Wilmington and Jay offer more accessible entry points into the Adirondack lifestyle, featuring a mix of seasonal and permanent housing options.

The eastern corridor, including Ticonderoga and Crown Point, presents a different market dynamic with its proximity to Vermont and Lake Champlain. These historic communities offer colonial-era homes and waterfront properties at more moderate price points, attracting buyers from the Capital Region and New England who value the area's rich history and recreational opportunities along Lake Champlain's western shore.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Essex County's real estate market operates under unique constraints due to the Forever Wild provisions of the Adirondack Park, which limit development and create scarcity that drives property values. This regulatory environment means that buildable lots are precious commodities, and existing structures often carry premium valuations simply due to their grandfathered status within park boundaries.

The market exhibits surprising resilience during economic downturns, as the area's recreational and lifestyle appeal attracts cash buyers from metropolitan areas. Remote work trends have further accelerated interest in Essex County properties, with buyers seeking full-time residences that offer outdoor recreation and small-town charm while maintaining connectivity to urban centers through improved internet infrastructure.

Why Businesses Need Essex County, New York Agent Contact Data

Service providers targeting Essex County's real estate market require direct access to all 152 licensed agents, each of whom maintains email contact information for seamless communication. These agents serve diverse clienteles ranging from local families to international buyers seeking Adirondack retreats, creating opportunities for specialized services including luxury home staging, environmental assessments, and recreational property management solutions.

The tight-knit nature of Essex County's real estate community means that building relationships with agents opens doors to repeat business and referral opportunities across the region. Whether offering mortgage services, home inspection capabilities, or property management solutions, companies that establish strong connections with local agents position themselves to capture business in a market where personal recommendations carry exceptional weight and seasonal demand creates concentrated periods of high activity.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Karen Mergenthaler has 3 properties for sale in Lake Placid and surrounding areas.

$2,250,000

Listed 2025-12-12

202 Victor Herbert Rd
Lake Placid, NY  12946

Beds: 5.0
Baths: 5.5
Sq Ft: 5,410
Lot: 12,197 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$325,000

Listed 2025-08-18

38 Denton Rd
Elizabethtown, NY  12932

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 1,200
Lot: 1,406,988 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$80,000

Listed 2025-08-10

7 Whiteface Inn Int 2 Ln Unit 308
Lake Placid, NY  12946

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 3.0
Sq Ft: 1,883
Lot: 436 sf
Condos Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Karen Mergenthaler currently has no rental properties available in Lake Placid and surrounding areas. Check back later.