```

Karen P Pluff
Real Estate Agent
Peshtigo WI

(WI: )

22 years experience

REALTOR® 4 Active Listings Serves Marinette County, WI
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
New Home Real Estate Llc

Office Website
Office Address
N3091 Park Ave
Peshtigo, WI  54157
(Marinette County)
Office Phone
715-938-3008
Office Fax
Mobile
715-938-3008
Email
kare******@*****.com
Show Email for $5
Website

Service Areas

Coleman: WI Beaver: WI Middle Inlet: WI Crivitz: WI Stiles: WI Lena: WI Porterfield: WI Marinette: WI Oconto: WI Pensaukee: WI Peshtigo: WI Pound: WI Athelstane: WI Wausaukee: WI

About Karen Pluff

**Karen Pluff, Broker/Owner**

Karen Pluff leads a dedicated real estate firm serving Northeast Wisconsin and the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, with a particular focus on Marinette, Oconto, and Menominee Counties. Her commitment to excellence drives the company’s mission to deliver exceptional service to clients, whether they are buying or selling property.

With a strong emphasis on local knowledge and a wealth of real estate experience, Karen and her team create tailored marketing strategies designed to maximize exposure and achieve optimal sale prices for homes. They recognize the unique appeal of Northeast Wisconsin and the Upper Peninsula, and are eager to share their enthusiasm for the diverse communities within the region. Their goal is to establish lasting relationships with clients, ensuring that their real estate needs are met with professionalism and care.

The firm operates with competitive commission rates starting at just 4% on all listings. As an independently owned company, they maintain lower overhead costs, allowing them to pass on savings to their clients without compromising on service quality. They are not a discount or limited-service agency; rather, they offer full-service real estate solutions at a competitive rate.

As members of the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), the firm’s listings are accessible through Realtor.com, the largest national real estate search platform. This affiliation enables them to collaborate with other real estate offices, enhancing the visibility of their listings through co-brokerage agreements. Their partnership with the Milwaukee Metro MLS further expands their reach and network.

Karen’s office is strategically located in Peshtigo, where she leverages her Marketing and Advertising degree along with over 30 years of corporate experience. Her dedication to the industry has earned her the prestigious Realtor of the Year award in 2018, as well as leadership roles as President and Vice President of the local Realtors Association. In addition to her professional commitments, she actively participates in various committees and charitable initiatives.

Karen, along with her husband Bill, also owns Hunters Choice Archery Pro Shop & Indoor Range in Peshtigo, reflecting their deep-rooted connection to the community. Growing up in Marinette County, Karen takes pride in providing exceptional real estate services to her local area.

For personalized assistance with your real estate needs, please reach out to Karen Pluff.

Marinette County, WI Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$329,119
Avg. Listing Price
From Karen's portfolio
2.9 / 1.8
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
1,739 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
195
Active Listings
Current inventory

Marinette County, Wisconsin's real estate market represents a unique blend of waterfront properties, rural acreage, and small-town charm that attracts both seasonal residents and year-round homeowners. Located along the stunning shores of Green Bay and bordered by Michigan's Upper Peninsula, this northeastern Wisconsin county offers some of the state's most diverse property types, from lakefront cabins to working farmland. The market here moves at a different pace than urban centers, with properties often staying on the market longer but maintaining steady appreciation due to the area's natural beauty and recreational opportunities.

With exactly 47 total actively licensed agents serving the county, Marinette County maintains a remarkably intimate real estate community where relationships and local knowledge drive transactions. What's particularly noteworthy is that all 47 agents have email addresses, indicating a tech-savvy professional network that's adapted well to modern communication methods despite serving a largely rural market. This complete digital connectivity suggests that even in Wisconsin's more remote counties, real estate professionals understand the importance of staying accessible to clients who may be relocating from urban areas or searching from out of state.

Major Marinette County, Wisconsin Real Estate Markets

The city of Marinette serves as the county's primary real estate hub, offering the most diverse housing stock from historic downtown properties to newer subdivisions near the Menominee River. Peshtigo, famous for its historical significance, has emerged as a surprising hotspot for affordable family homes, while Crivitz draws buyers seeking proximity to both recreational opportunities and reasonable commutes. The Wausaukee area appeals to those wanting larger parcels and rural privacy, often featuring properties with significant acreage for farming or recreational use.

Waterfront communities along Green Bay, including areas near Stephenson Island and the numerous inland lakes, command premium prices and often see the most competitive bidding situations. These markets tend to be seasonal, with peak activity occurring between April and September when out-of-state buyers can fully appreciate the area's recreational potential. The contrast between waterfront and inland pricing can be dramatic, with lakefront properties sometimes selling for three times the price of comparable inland homes just a few miles away.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Marinette County's real estate market operates with fascinating micro-climates that reflect the area's geographic diversity and economic drivers. Properties near the Menominee River and industrial areas tend to move more quickly and appeal to working families, while remote recreational properties may sit on the market for months before finding the right buyer. The county's proximity to both Wisconsin's Northwoods and Michigan's Upper Peninsula creates unique cross-border dynamics, with some buyers specifically seeking Wisconsin properties for tax advantages.

Seasonal fluctuations significantly impact market timing, with winter months seeing dramatically reduced activity except for year-round residential properties in town centers. The county's substantial forest land and agricultural properties create additional complexity, as these transactions often involve specialized knowledge of timber rights, agricultural zoning, and conservation programs that many agents outside the area might not fully understand.

Why Businesses Need Marinette County, Wisconsin Agent Contact Data

For mortgage lenders and real estate service providers, having direct access to all 47 licensed agents in Marinette County is crucial given the specialized nature of many local transactions. These agents handle everything from complex waterfront appraisals to rural properties with unique financing challenges, making them valuable partners for businesses offering specialized lending products, title services, or property management solutions. The county's mix of seasonal and permanent residents also creates opportunities for businesses serving vacation rental markets, property maintenance services, and seasonal home preparation.

Marketing and lead generation companies find Marinette County particularly interesting because the small agent population means less competition for attention, while the diverse property types create multiple niche marketing opportunities. With all agents maintaining email communication, businesses can efficiently reach the entire market while crafting messages that address the unique challenges of selling everything from hunting land to historic downtown properties in this distinctive Wisconsin market.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Karen Pluff has 4 properties for sale in Peshtigo and surrounding areas.

$339,900

Listed 2026-01-30

180 S Beebe Ave
Peshtigo, WI  54157

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,335
Lot: 16,553 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$44,900

Listed 2025-08-26

N12051 Holly Rd
Athelstane, WI  54104

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 13,504 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$229,900

Listed 2025-11-08

723 Water St
Marinette, WI  54143

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,800
Lot: 5,227 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$184,900

Listed 2026-01-13

130 S Franklin St
Oconto Falls, WI  54154

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft: 2,287
Lot: 14,375 sf
Multi Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Karen Pluff currently has no rental properties available in Peshtigo and surrounding areas. Check back later.