```
Katherine Cain

Katherine Cain
Real Estate Agent
Plymouth WI

(WI: )

26 years experience

REALTOR® 6 Active Listings Serves Sheboygan County, WI
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Avenue Real Estate Llc
Office Address
410 S Milwaukee St
Plymouth, WI  53073
(Sheboygan County)
Office Phone
920-893-3001
Office Fax
888-690-6696
Mobile
920-980-9302
Email
k***@*********.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Adell: WI Belgium: WI Fredonia: WI Campbellsport: WI Cascade: WI Cedarburg: WI Cedar Grove: WI Chilton: WI Stockbridge: WI Cleveland: WI Eden: WI Elkhart Lake: WI Waubeka: WI Glenbeulah: WI Greenbush: WI Port Washington: WI Saukville: WI Grafton: WI Hingham: WI Kiel: WI Sheboygan Falls: WI Kohler: WI Malone: WI St. Peter: WI Mount Calvary: WI New Holstein: WI Newton: WI Oakfield: WI Byron: WI Oostburg: WI Gibbsville: WI Plymouth: WI Random Lake: WI St. Cloud: WI Sheboygan: WI Haven: WI Howards Grove: WI Newburg: WI West Bend: WI Waldo: WI Fairwater: WI Brandon: WI Waupun: WI Forest Junction: WI Potter: WI Brillion: WI Hilbert: WI Sherwood: WI Collins: WI Francis Creek: WI Manitowoc: WI Cato: WI Two Rivers: WI Maribel: WI Mishicot: WI Whitelaw: WI Reedsville: WI Kellnersville: WI St. Nazianz: WI Tisch Mills: WI Valders: WI Branch: WI Eldorado: WI Fond du Lac: WI Taycheedah: WI North Fond du Lac: WI Ripon: WI Rosendale: WI Van Dyne: WI

About Katherine Cain

Thank you for taking the time to learn more about Katherine. As a dedicated Realtor and Auctioneer, [he/she/they] serves the counties of Sheboygan, Ozaukee, Manitowoc, and Calumet. Katherine is committed to delivering exceptional customer service while leveraging the latest technology to benefit clients, whether they are buyers or sellers.

Specializing in first-time home buyers and relocation services, [he/she/they] understands the diverse needs and life stages of clients navigating the real estate market. Outside of work, Katherine enjoys gardening, water sports, charity auctions, grilling, and following football and baseball.

[His/Her/Their] guiding principle is to provide "Service You Deserve & A Relationship You Can Trust." Katherine welcomes the opportunity to assist you—please feel free to reach out via phone or email to discuss how [he/she/they] can support your real estate needs.

Sheboygan County, WI Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$455,897
Avg. Listing Price
From Katherine's portfolio
3.4 / 2.3
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
1,954 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
251
Active Listings
Current inventory

Sheboygan County's real estate market reflects the unique character of Wisconsin's eastern lakeshore region, where Lake Michigan proximity drives both residential desirability and commercial opportunity. The county's 236 actively licensed real estate agents serve a diverse landscape that spans from the industrial city of Sheboygan to charming lakeside communities like Sheboygan Falls and Cedar Grove, creating a market that balances urban convenience with small-town appeal.

What makes Sheboygan County particularly intriguing is its surprising resilience during market fluctuations, largely due to its manufacturing base anchored by companies like Kohler Co. and Johnsonville Sausage. This economic stability has created steady housing demand while keeping prices more accessible than many Wisconsin lakefront markets. The county's agents navigate everything from historic homes in downtown Sheboygan to modern lakefront properties in Oostburg, requiring deep local knowledge that sets successful practitioners apart.

Major Sheboygan County, Wisconsin Real Estate Markets

The city of Sheboygan dominates the county's real estate activity, offering the most diverse inventory from riverfront condominiums to established neighborhoods like Woodlake and South Side. Plymouth serves as the county's second-largest market, attracting buyers seeking small-city amenities with excellent school districts and reasonable commutes to larger employment centers. Sheboygan Falls has emerged as a hidden gem, with its historic downtown and proximity to recreational areas driving increased interest from both local and out-of-state buyers.

Lake Michigan communities like Oostburg and Cedar Grove represent the county's premium market segments, where waterfront properties and lake access drive higher valuations. These smaller markets require agents with specialized knowledge of seasonal fluctuations, as summer months typically see increased activity from buyers seeking vacation homes or permanent relocations from urban areas. The agricultural communities of Random Lake and Adell offer unique opportunities in rural residential properties, often appealing to buyers seeking larger lots and agricultural potential.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Sheboygan County's real estate patterns are heavily influenced by seasonal tourism and the county's role as a manufacturing hub, creating interesting timing dynamics that savvy agents learn to navigate. Summer months bring increased activity in lakefront areas, while spring typically sees the strongest overall market movement as families time moves around school schedules. The county's proximity to Milwaukee and Green Bay creates commuter demand that supports steady residential sales even during slower periods.

Geographic diversity within the county means agents often specialize in specific niches, whether that's downtown Sheboygan's historic properties, lakefront luxury homes, or rural acreage sales. This specialization creates opportunities for collaboration among the county's 236 licensed professionals, as cross-referrals become essential for serving clients with varying needs across the county's distinct market segments.

Why Businesses Need Sheboygan County, Wisconsin Agent Contact Data

With all 236 licensed agents maintaining email contact information, Sheboygan County offers remarkable connectivity for businesses seeking to reach real estate professionals efficiently. Mortgage lenders, home improvement contractors, and insurance providers can leverage this complete contact coverage to build relationships across the county's diverse market segments, from high-end lakefront specialists to rural property experts.

The county's concentrated agent population creates unique opportunities for targeted marketing campaigns and professional service offerings. Title companies, real estate attorneys, and property management firms benefit from direct access to agents who understand local market nuances and can provide qualified referrals, making comprehensive contact data essential for building sustainable business relationships in this tight-knit professional community.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Katherine Cain has 6 properties for sale in Plymouth and surrounding areas.

$309,900

Listed 2026-01-09

411 S 4th Ave
Saint Nazianz, WI  54232

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 2,635
Lot: 38,333 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$162,900

Listed 2025-06-20

W5790 Emerald Ln
Plymouth, WI  53073

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 130,680 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$387,900

Listed 2026-01-30

427 Limestone St
Kiel, WI  53042

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 3.0
Sq Ft: 2,167
Lot: 13,504 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$1,350,000

Listed 2025-07-18

74 West St
Elkhart Lake, WI  53020

Beds: 7.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 4,000
Lot: 7,405 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$1,350,000

Listed 2025-07-18

74 West St Unit 84
Elkhart Lake, WI  53020

Beds: 7.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 4,000
Lot: 7,405 sf
Multi Family Map
View Full Details

$575,000

Listed 2025-07-18

N8362 State Highway 67
Rhine, WI  53020

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,682
Lot: 169,448 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Katherine Cain currently has no rental properties available in Plymouth and surrounding areas. Check back later.