```
Mary McCoskey Finkle

Mary McCoskey Finkle
Real Estate Agent
Salem - IN

(IN: )

37 years experience

REALTOR® 25 Active Listings Serves Washington County, IN
View on Realtor.com

About Mary McCoskey Finkle

Mary McCoskey Finkle serves as the Managing Broker and Owner of Mainstreet Realtors, bringing over 30 years of real estate expertise to her clients. A native of Southern Indiana, Mary began her career in Salem and has also spent 16 years as a Realtor in California, enriching her perspective and approach to real estate transactions. Her extensive experience has positioned her as a multi-million-dollar producer in both states.

As a Principal Broker and Realtor, Mary is driven by a commitment to making homeownership a reality for each client. She emphasizes integrity and a personalized approach, ensuring that individual needs are met throughout the buying or selling process. Mary has cultivated a strong team of dedicated professionals within her office, who assist in managing the intricate details of real estate transactions. In 2015 alone, this committed group facilitated over $19 million in home sales.

The Mainstreet Realtors team is well-equipped to assist clients across Southern Indiana with a variety of real estate needs, including buying, selling, short sales, auctions, and rentals. They specialize in residential relocations, first-time homebuyers, commercial properties, and new construction. By leveraging multiple marketing resources and affiliations with three different Multiple Listing Services throughout Southern Indiana, the team maximizes exposure for listings, ensuring that homes reach a broad audience.

Mary has also established a solid reputation as an REO/Foreclosure Specialist, building relationships with numerous banks and government institutions over the past 14 years. Her expertise in the foreclosure market involves meticulous attention to detail and strategic planning, allowing her and her team to provide exceptional service in managing bank-owned properties.

For inquiries, Mary is readily available via her cell phone at 812-620-0212 or at the office at 812-883-9555. She can also be reached via email at mainst@blueriver.net.

Washington County, IN Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$238,909
Avg. Listing Price
From Mary's portfolio
2.9 / 1.8
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
1,713 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
86
Active Listings
Current inventory

Washington County, Indiana presents a unique real estate landscape characterized by rural charm and small-town appeal. Located in southern Indiana, this county encompasses communities like Salem, the county seat, along with smaller towns such as Campbellsburg, Fredericksburg, and Little York. The market here reflects the broader trends of rural Indiana, where agricultural properties, modest residential homes, and historic properties define much of the available inventory.

What makes Washington County particularly intriguing is its extremely limited real estate agent population, with only 3 total actively licensed agents serving the entire county. This creates an unusually concentrated market where each agent potentially handles a significant portion of local transactions, making professional relationships and local expertise absolutely critical for anyone looking to buy or sell property in the area.

Major Washington County, Indiana Real Estate Markets

Salem dominates as the primary real estate hub within Washington County, serving as both the county seat and largest population center. The town offers a mix of historic homes, newer developments, and commercial properties that cater to local businesses and government operations. Rural properties surrounding Salem include working farms, recreational land, and residential acreage that appeals to buyers seeking privacy and space.

The smaller communities of Campbellsburg, Fredericksburg, and Pekin each contribute their own character to the county's real estate market. These areas typically feature more affordable housing options, often with larger lots and rural settings. The geographic spread of these communities across the county means that local knowledge becomes essential, as property values, zoning regulations, and development potential can vary significantly from one township to another.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

The concentration of just 3 licensed agents across the entire county creates fascinating market dynamics. Unlike urban areas where dozens or hundreds of agents compete, Washington County's real estate professionals likely develop deep specialization in local markets, extensive networks with area lenders and service providers, and intimate knowledge of property histories and neighborhood trends that would be impossible to replicate in larger markets.

This agent scarcity also means that timing and relationships matter enormously. Properties may receive less marketing exposure than in agent-saturated markets, while buyers might face longer searches for suitable properties. The rural nature of much of the county adds complexity, as agricultural zoning, septic systems, well water, and property access issues require specialized knowledge that these few agents must possess to serve their clients effectively.

Why Businesses Need Washington County, Indiana Agent Contact Data

For mortgage lenders, insurance providers, and real estate service companies, having direct contact information for Washington County's 3 licensed agents represents access to virtually the entire local market. With all 3 agents maintaining email contact capabilities, businesses can efficiently reach the complete network of active real estate professionals in the county through targeted communications and partnership opportunities.

Property investors, developers, and businesses looking to establish locations in Washington County will find these agent contacts invaluable for market intelligence and deal flow. Given the limited number of professionals handling transactions, building relationships with these agents could provide early access to listings, market insights, and local knowledge that simply isn't available through online platforms or outside brokers unfamiliar with the county's unique characteristics and opportunities.

Contact Information

Brokerage
Mainstreet Realtors

Office Website
Office Address
304 N MAIN ST
Salem, IN  47167
(Washington County)
Office Phone
812-883-9555
Office Fax
812-883-5234
Mobile
812-620-0212
Email
info@************

Service Areas

Campbellsburg: IN Northeast: IN Livonia: IN Saltillo: IN New Albany: IN Otisco: IN Bradford: IN Palmyra: IN Pekin: IN New Pekin: IN Ramsey: IN Salem: IN Speed: IN Clarksville: IN Sellersburg: IN Jeffersonville: IN Scottsburg: IN Lexington: IN Little York: IN Huron: IN Halbert: IN Mitchell: IN Guthrie: IN Stampers Creek: IN Paoli: IN Eckerty: IN New Middletown: IN Corydon: IN Borden: IN Starlight: IN Hardinsburg: IN Valeene: IN Rego: IN Georgetown: IN Lanesville: IN Floyds Knobs: IN Galena: IN Navilleton: IN Mount Saint Francis: IN Henryville: IN Memphis: IN

Current Property Listings

As of 1/31/2026, Mary McCoskey Finkle has 25 properties for sale in Salem and surrounding areas. These are the top 10 listings.

$219,900

Listed 2025-08-02

250 E Hospital Rd
Paoli, IN  47454

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,334
Lot: 63,162 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$125,000

Listed 2026-01-23

2911 Washington Ave
Bedford, IN  47421

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,776
Lot: 11,326 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$1,500,000

Listed 2025-07-24

100 Walnut Tree Dr
Salem, IN  47167

Beds: 32.0
Baths: 23.0
Sq Ft: 41,734
Lot: 91,476 sf
Multi Family Map
View Full Details

$130,000

Listed 2025-04-23

701 S Main St
Salem, IN  47167

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 43,560 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$199,900

Listed 2025-10-14

1771 N Rush Creek Rd
Salem, IN  47167

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.5
Sq Ft: 1,764
Lot: 108,900 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$219,900

Listed 2025-09-25

3634 W State Road 60
Salem, IN  47167

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,860
Lot: 54,450 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$274,900

Listed 2025-08-15

301 E Market St
Salem, IN  47167

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,640
Lot: 7,405 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$249,900

Listed 2025-11-10

6430 E Old 56
Salem, IN  47167

Beds: 7.0
Baths:
Sq Ft: 2,464
Lot: 130,680 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$49,900

Listed 2025-11-05

S S # 160
Salem, IN  47167

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft:
Lot: 39,640 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$220,000

Listed 2025-10-19

5418 E Mann Rd
Pekin, IN  47165

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,544
Lot: 43,560 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Mary McCoskey Finkle currently has no rental properties available in Salem and surrounding areas. Check back later.