```
Michelle McCulloch

Michelle McCulloch
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Warsaw NY

Salesperson (NY: 10401355401)

5 years experience

REALTOR® 2 Active Listings Serves Wyoming County, NY
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Wny Metro Roberts Realty

Office Website
Office Address
2371 Rte 19 Ste A
Warsaw, NY  14569
(Wyoming County)
Office Phone
585-968-4450
Office Fax
Mobile
585-329-0963
Email
mich*************@*****.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Attica: NY Alexander: NY Darien: NY Alabama: NY Stafford: NY Pembroke: NY Batavia: NY Crittenden: NY Royalton: NY Newstead: NY Akron: NY Town Line: NY Marilla: NY Lancaster: NY Elma: NY Alden: NY Warsaw: NY York: NY Caledonia: NY Fowlerville: NY Rush: NY Pavilion: NY Wyoming: NY East Bethany: NY Corfu: NY Billington Heights: NY East Aurora: NY Sheldon: NY Varysburg: NY Cowlesville: NY Darien Center: NY Strykersville: NY Castile: NY Depew: NY Cheektowaga: NY Mount Morris: NY Tuscarora: NY Groveland: NY Springwater: NY Conesus: NY Conesus Lake: NY Conesus Hamlet: NY Lakeville: NY Geneseo: NY Cuylerville: NY Leicester: NY Piffard: NY Greigsville: NY Wadsworth: NY York Hamlet: NY Retsof: NY Harris Hill: NY Clarence: NY Clarence Center: NY University at Buffalo: NY Amherst: NY Williamsville: NY Perry: NY Spring Brook: NY Elma Center: NY South Wales: NY Linwood: NY Le Roy: NY Wheatland: NY Buffalo: NY

About Michelle McCulloch

Dedicated to serving clients, this full-time real estate agent transitioned from a conventional career to advocate for those navigating the complexities of real estate. With a genuine enthusiasm for the industry, she is committed to guiding clients from the initial consultation through to the closing day. Her focus on clear communication and meticulous attention to detail ensures a smooth and efficient experience for buyers and sellers alike.

Wyoming County, NY Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$258,279
Avg. Listing Price
From Michelle's portfolio
3.4 / 1.9
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
1,871 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
110
Active Listings
Current inventory

Wyoming County, New York represents one of the state's most distinctive rural real estate markets, characterized by vast agricultural landscapes, rolling hills, and small-town charm that attracts buyers seeking authentic country living. Despite being one of New York's least populated counties, the area maintains a surprisingly active real estate sector supported by 54 total actively licensed agents, all of whom maintain email contact information, creating an exceptionally connected professional network for such a rural market.

The county's real estate landscape reflects its agricultural heritage, with properties ranging from working farms and rural homesteads to charming village homes in historic communities. What makes Wyoming County particularly intriguing is its proximity to larger metropolitan areas while maintaining significantly lower property values, making it an emerging destination for remote workers and retirees seeking affordable rural retreats without complete isolation from urban amenities.

Major Wyoming County, New York Real Estate Markets

Warsaw serves as the county seat and primary real estate hub, offering the most diverse housing inventory from Victorian-era homes to modern developments. The village's historic downtown and established infrastructure make it attractive to families and professionals, while nearby Attica provides additional residential options with its mix of rural properties and village lots. Perry, in the county's eastern region, has gained attention for its scenic location and growing appeal among buyers seeking recreational properties.

The county's geographic positioning between Rochester and Buffalo creates unique market dynamics, with some areas experiencing spillover demand from commuters willing to travel for significantly lower housing costs. Smaller communities like Castile, Gainesville, and Silver Springs each offer distinct character and property types, from historic canal-era buildings to modern rural developments, creating diverse investment opportunities across different price points and property styles.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Wyoming County's real estate market operates on notably different timelines compared to urban areas, with seasonal fluctuations heavily influenced by agricultural cycles and weather patterns. Properties often remain on the market longer, but this creates opportunities for thorough due diligence and negotiation, particularly for unique rural properties like working farms, hunting land, and historic estates that require specialized knowledge to properly evaluate and market.

The market's complexity stems from its diverse property types and zoning considerations, ranging from residential village lots to expansive agricultural parcels with development potential. Environmental factors, including flood plains, agricultural soil quality, and access to utilities, significantly impact property values and marketability, requiring agents to possess deep local knowledge about everything from septic systems to mineral rights.

Why Businesses Need Wyoming County, New York Agent Contact Data

Companies serving the real estate industry find Wyoming County's tight-knit professional network invaluable, as the 54 licensed agents often collaborate on complex rural transactions and maintain extensive knowledge of local market conditions. Service providers, from mortgage companies to home inspectors, benefit from direct agent contact data to efficiently reach professionals who regularly handle unique property types requiring specialized expertise and vendor relationships.

The complete email accessibility of all active agents creates exceptional opportunities for targeted marketing of products and services relevant to rural real estate transactions. Whether offering agricultural property appraisal services, septic system inspections, or specialized insurance products, businesses can effectively reach the entire professional network through direct communication, maximizing their market penetration in this geographically dispersed but professionally connected county.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/5/2026, Michelle McCulloch has 2 properties for sale in Warsaw and surrounding areas.

$209,000

Listed 2025-11-25

7212 Derby Rd
Derby, NY  14047

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 1,236
Lot: 43,560 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$194,000

Listed 2025-11-15

3043 Dunbar Rd
Attica, NY  14011

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 1,008
Lot: 18,226 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Michelle McCulloch currently has no rental properties available in Warsaw and surrounding areas. Check back later.