Nancy M Newman May

Nancy M Newman May
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Sebring FL

Salesperson (FL: 3406733)

8 years experience

REALTOR® 5 Active Listings Serves Highlands County, FL
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Advantage Realty 1

Office Website
Office Address
743 Us 27 S
Sebring, FL  33870
(Highlands County)
Office Phone
863-386-0303
Office Fax
863-386-1112
Mobile
863-852-6687
Email
nmay121@gmail.com
Website

Service Areas

Sebring: FL Avon Park: FL Lake Placid: FL Frostproof: FL

About Nancy Newman May

Nancy May's journey in real estate began as a personal interest and has evolved into a thriving career spanning over 24 years. Throughout her extensive experience, she has navigated the market's fluctuations, consistently achieving profitable outcomes for her investments. As a dedicated real estate professional, Nancy is committed to guiding clients through the complexities of buying and selling both residential and commercial properties.

Her approach is grounded in principles of honesty, integrity, and exceptional customer service. Nancy prioritizes her clients' needs, ensuring that every transaction receives meticulous attention and that their voices are heard.

Recognized as a multi-million-dollar producer in her local market, Nancy combines her expertise with a passion for community service. She and her husband founded A Heart Like His Foundation Inc., a non-profit organization dedicated to addressing hunger among children both locally and globally. In support of this mission, Nancy donates 10% of her real estate commissions to the foundation, reflecting her commitment to making a positive impact in the lives of those in need.

Highlands County, FL Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$343,176
Avg. Listing Price
From Nancy's portfolio
3.0 / 2.2
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,433 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
844
Active Listings
Current inventory

If you need to reach working real estate agents in Highlands County, Florida, this list was built for you. Mortgage lenders, title companies, PropTech platforms, E&O insurers, continuing education providers, and real estate recruiters all rely on targeted agent data to drive pipeline — and a county-level list puts your message directly in front of the professionals most likely to respond, without paying to reach agents three counties away who will never send you a deal.

Whether you are launching a cold email sequence through a platform like Zap Contact (zapcontact.com) or another dedicated cold-email tool, running a direct mail drop, or building a LinkedIn matched audience, the foundation is the same: accurate, current contact data for licensed agents in your target market. This list includes {{AGENT_COUNT}} actively licensed Highlands County agents with verified email addresses, plus {{CELL_COUNT}} agents who also have cell phone numbers on file — giving you multiple channels from a single purchase.

Why Buy a Highlands County Real Estate Agent Email List From Dr Bill

Dr Bill has been selling real estate agent lists since 2005 and has delivered over 31,000 lists to lenders, vendors, and service providers across the country. Every record is sourced directly from the Florida state licensing board — not scraped from aggregator sites or cobbled together from outdated directories. New emails are added weekly, the full list is cleaned monthly, and the entire database is completely refreshed bi-annually, which is why Dr Bill can guarantee 96% deliverability — a standard most cheap data vendors cannot come close to matching.

Generic list sellers often bundle counties together or sell you a statewide file you have to filter yourself, and their data may not have been touched in over a year. With Dr Bill, you are buying a living dataset with a real deliverability guarantee behind it. If you buy a Highlands County real estate agent email list from a discount provider, you often get bounce rates that tank your sending reputation before your first campaign is even finished.

How to Use This Highlands County Agent List

Email outreach is the highest-volume use case — load the file directly into Zap Contact or a similar cold-email platform and launch segmented sequences by broker versus sales agent, which is a distinction included in the data. You can also use the list for direct mail, SMS campaigns using the included cell numbers, or upload it as a custom audience for LinkedIn advertising to reach these agents across channels simultaneously.

Segmenting by broker versus sales agent alone can double your response rates because the message that resonates with a team leader is completely different from what a solo agent needs to hear. The city and zip code fields also let you focus tightly on specific offices or neighborhoods within the county.

Why Highlands County, Florida Agent Data Matters

Highlands County covers a distinct market anchored by Sebring, Avon Park, and Lake Placid — communities with their own agent ecosystems that rarely overlap with agents working in Orlando or Tampa. With {{AGENT_COUNT}} licensed agents operating in this county, there is a real, reachable audience here, and no other vendor currently offers this list segmented down to the zip code level within Highlands County, which means you can target agents in a single zip without buying the entire county file.

Local targeting beats statewide blasts every time because relevance drives opens and opens drive responses. An agent in Sebring is not competing for the same clients as an agent in Sarasota, and your offer should reflect that. Highlands County-specific data lets you personalize your outreach by market, build credibility with local references, and avoid the noise of a 200,000-record statewide file where your message gets lost entirely.

Current Property Listings

As of 6/27/2026, Nancy Newman May has 5 properties for sale in Sebring and surrounding areas.

$294,900

Listed 2026-03-05

4441 Palmarito St
Sebring, FL  33872

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 2,183
Lot: 10,019 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$20,000

Listed 2019-02-07

8739 Oviedo St
Sebring, FL  33872

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft: 0
Lot: 10,890 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$20,000

Listed 2019-02-07

8747 Oviedo St
Sebring, FL  33872

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft: 0
Lot: 10,454 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$17,000

Listed 2025-06-07

1110 Viburnum Dr
Sebring, FL  33875

Beds:
Baths:
Sq Ft: 0
Lot: 20,473 sf
Land Map
View Full Details

$243,000

Listed 2026-03-02

2052 W Stryker Rd
Avon Park, FL  33825

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,480
Lot: 13,504 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Nancy Newman May currently has no rental properties available in Sebring and surrounding areas. Check back later.