Nickie O'Toole

Nickie O'Toole
Real Estate Agent (Broker)
Seymour CT

Broker (CT: REB.0755523)

2 years experience

REALTOR® 2 Active Listings Serves New Haven County, CT
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Nickie O'Toole
Office Address
29 Deer Run Dr
Seymour, CT  06483
(New Haven County)
Office Phone
203-888-3921
Office Fax
203-888-7007
Mobile
203-888-3921
Email
realestate@nickieotoole.com

Service Areas

Ansonia: CT Town Of Beacon Falls: CT Beacon Falls: CT Derby: CT Oxford: CT Seymour: CT Shelton: CT Huntington: CT Bridgeport: CT Naugatuck: CT

About Nickie O'Toole

**Nickie O'Toole Realty LLC**

With over a decade of experience as a real estate agent and Associate Broker, Nickie O'Toole has established her own independent brokerage to provide exceptional service to her clients. Known for her commitment and diligence, she has consistently excelled in both selling properties and assisting clients in finding their ideal homes, regardless of market conditions.

Nickie takes a comprehensive approach to understanding the true marketability of each property. Her expertise extends beyond aesthetics; she evaluates homes from the foundation to the roof, ensuring that there are no unexpected issues for buyers or sellers. Clients appreciate her candid honesty and in-depth knowledge of home construction, mechanical systems, and maintenance, all of which contribute to a clear understanding of property value.

Value is a critical factor in the real estate process, influencing how quickly a home sells and how smoothly a buyer can navigate their commitment. Nickie’s dedication to her clients is evident from the initial consultation through to the closing, as she works tirelessly to deliver value at every stage.

In the current market, with interest rates significantly below historical averages, there has never been a better time to secure financing for a home. This presents an opportunity for substantial savings, making it a valuable investment for the future. Nickie looks forward to bringing this value to both buyers and sellers alike.

New Haven County, CT Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$641,633
Avg. Listing Price
From Nickie's portfolio
3.4 / 2.4
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,130 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
1765
Active Listings
Current inventory

If you need to reach working real estate agents in New Haven County, Connecticut, this list was built for you. Mortgage lenders, title companies, and insurance providers use it to put their services directly in front of active producers. PropTech companies use it to demo new tools. Continuing education providers use it to fill courses. Recruiters use it to identify experienced agents worth poaching. Whatever your offer, the agents on this list are licensed, active, and reachable.

This list includes {{AGENT_COUNT}} actively licensed real estate agents in New Haven County with verified email addresses, plus {{CELL_COUNT}} agents with cell phone numbers included. Whether you are running a cold email sequence through a platform like Zap Contact (zapcontact.com) or another cold-email tool, or building a direct mail or phone outreach campaign, this data gives you a real foundation to work from rather than guessing who is even in the market.

Why Buy a New Haven County Real Estate Agent Email List From Dr Bill

Dr. Bill has been selling real estate agent lists since 2005 and has moved over 31,000 lists to marketers, lenders, vendors, and recruiters across the country. Every record is sourced directly from the Connecticut state real estate licensing board, which means you are not getting scraped web data or recycled broker rosters. New emails are added weekly, the full list is cleaned monthly, and the entire database is refreshed from source bi-annually. That process backs a 96% deliverability guarantee, which is not a number most cheap data vendors will even put in writing.

When you buy New Haven County real estate agent email list data from a discount provider, you typically get stale records, high bounce rates, and no recourse. Dr. Bill's process is the opposite. If deliverability falls below 96%, it gets made right. That standard of accountability is what 20 years in the business looks like.

How to Use This New Haven County Agent List

Cold email is the most common use case, and platforms like Zap Contact make it straightforward to upload a segmented list and launch a targeted sequence the same day. You can also use this data for direct mail drops, SMS or phone outreach to the agents who have cell numbers on file, or to build a matched audience for LinkedIn advertising. Each of those channels works better when your list is current and clean.

The list can be segmented by broker versus individual sales agent, which matters when your offer is meant for decision-makers at the office level rather than every agent on the floor. That kind of targeting precision keeps your cost per response down.

Why New Haven County, Connecticut Agent Data Matters

New Haven County includes a wide range of active real estate markets, from the urban density of New Haven and Hamden to suburban communities like Milford, Wallingford, and Cheshire. With {{AGENT_COUNT}} licensed agents operating across these distinct markets, county-level targeting lets you speak to a concentrated professional audience without paying for irrelevant statewide records.

No other vendor currently offers this list segmented down to the zip code level within New Haven County. That granularity means you can focus your campaign on Naugatuck or North Haven specifically rather than blasting the entire state and hoping for relevance. Local precision is what converts outreach into actual conversations.

Current Property Listings

As of 6/21/2026, Nickie O'Toole has 2 properties for sale in Seymour and surrounding areas.

$452,900

Listed 2026-05-16

14 Poplar Dr
Seymour, CT  06483

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.5
Sq Ft: 2,436
Lot: 12,632 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$525,000

Listed 2026-04-21

17 Autumn Ridge Rd
Oxford, CT  06478

Beds: 2.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,356
Lot: 85,378 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Nickie O'Toole currently has no rental properties available in Seymour and surrounding areas. Check back later.