Sandra Tuttle

Sandra Tuttle
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Summerland Key - FL

Salesperson (FL: 3093204)

22 years experience

REALTOR® 6 Active Listings Serves Monroe County, FL
View on Realtor.com

About Sandra Tuttle

Sandy Tuttle is a distinguished real estate professional in the Florida Keys, recognized for her expertise in the luxury market. With an impressive track record of 40 to 50 transactions annually, she has facilitated numerous record-setting sales, showcasing her unparalleled knowledge, experience, and problem-solving skills. Sandy's accolades include ranking in the top 1% of agents nationwide in 2018 and 2019, and the top 5% in 2020 and 2021 at her previous firm. Her credentials encompass a range of designations, such as Luxury Collection Specialist, Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist, e-PRO®, Green Designation, and At Home with Diversity® certifications. Her local prominence has also led to appearances on HGTV, where she shared her insights on popular shows like House Hunters and Beachfront Bargain Hunt.

Originally hailing from New Jersey, Sandy spent her childhood summers at the Jersey Shore and vacationing in the Florida Keys, where she dreamed of establishing a permanent residence. Initially aspiring to work in animal husbandry, she earned a degree in animal behavior from a Maryland university before moving to Thailand to teach English. Sandy also embarked on an adventurous trek through the Himalayas in Nepal.

In 1998, Sandy's dream materialized when she and her husband settled in the Florida Keys as the live-aboard crew of a 55-foot sailing vessel based in Marathon. After several years of exploring the Keys and the Bahamas, she obtained her real estate license in 2004. This career path allowed her to secure her future in the Keys, fueled by her determination, strong work ethic, and passion for sharing the region's exceptional lifestyle with newcomers. Her mother, a respected top-producing Realtor® in New Jersey, instilled in Sandy the importance of client service and relationship-building.

Transitioning to a full-time agent in 2005, Sandy has consistently surpassed her previous achievements, breaking records and exceeding expectations. She is dedicated to guiding buyers and sellers through their real estate journeys, prioritizing their needs and maintaining open communication throughout each transaction. Sandy excels at transforming challenges into opportunities, leveraging her creativity and extensive community network to provide clients with the best resources available.

Monroe County, FL Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$2,715,329
Avg. Listing Price
From Sandra's portfolio
3.4 / 3.1
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,128 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
1024
Active Listings
Current inventory

Contact Information

Brokerage
Island Welcome Real Estate

Office Website
Office Address
24437 Overseas Hwy
Summerland Key, FL  33042
(Monroe County)
Office Phone
305-389-2922
Office Fax
Mobile
305-923-****
Email
sandy@************

Service Areas

Little Torch Key: FL Middle Torch Key: FL Cudjoe Key: FL Summerland Key: FL Sugarloaf: FL Lower Sugarloaf Key: FL Ramrod Key: FL Upper Sugarloaf Key: FL Big Torch Key: FL Sugarloaf Key: FL

Current Property Listings

Sandra Tuttle currently has 6 properties available in Summerland Key and surrounding areas.

$995,000

Listed 2025-08-10

687 and 689 Crane Blvd
Sugarloaf, FL33042

Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 2,080
Lot: 34,412 sf
multi_family Map
View Full Details

$850,000

Listed 2024-12-19

31463 Avenue G
Big Pine Key, FL33043

Beds: 2
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,260
Lot: 7,397 sf
single_family Map
View Full Details

$1,990,000

Listed 2025-06-25

20771 W 2nd Ave
Cudjoe Key, FL33042

Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 2,047
Lot: 10,000 sf
single_family Map
View Full Details

$1,495,000

Listed 2025-03-04

27001 Overseas Hwy
Ramrod Key, FL33042

Beds: 1
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,234
Lot: 7,405 sf
single_family Map
View Full Details

$1,125,000

Listed 2025-05-13

17126 W Wahoo Ln
Sugarloaf, FL33042

Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,152
Lot: 12,632 sf
single_family Map
View Full Details

$1,125,000

Listed 2025-08-22

27417 Tobago Ln
Ramrod Key, FL33042

Beds: 3
Baths: 2
Sq Ft: 1,494
Lot: 6,000 sf
single_family Map
View Full Details