```
Shelby Teel

Shelby Teel
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Pinetop AZ

Salesperson (AZ: SA657819000)

11 years experience

REALTOR® 5 Active Listings Serves Navajo County, AZ
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Frank M Smith & Assoc - Main

Office Website
Office Address
4756 Buck Springs Rd
Pinetop, AZ  85935
(Navajo County)
Office Phone
928-369-4000
Office Fax
928-369-1383
Mobile
928-369-4000
Email
wmre********@*****.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Pinetop: AZ McNary: AZ North Fork: AZ Pinetop-Lakeside: AZ Hondah: AZ Pinetop Country Club: AZ Wagon Wheel: AZ Lakeside: AZ Show Low: AZ Lake of the Woods: AZ White Mountain Lake: AZ Vernon: AZ Linden: AZ Pinedale: AZ Taylor: AZ Clay Springs: AZ

About Shelby Teel

Shelby has been a licensed Realtor in the state of Arizona since 2015   She is the third generation of women in her family to sell real estate for Frank M Smith & Associates   Shelby has the best mentor her mother who is the designated Broker for Frank M Smith & Associates Inc

?Shelby was born and raised in the White Mountain’s and plans to live here happily  for the rest of her life   She has a deep passion for this area and cherishes the place she calls home   You could say she is a White Mountain expert who knows the area the hiking trails the lakes restaurants subdivisions etc   Her plan is to help her clients know the area as well as she does so when they move into their new home/town they feel comfortable   

?Currently Shelby represent the Pinetop-Lakeside area on the Board of Directors for the White Mountain Association of Realtors and will continue serving her term until 2020   She is also the Liaison for the WMAR Functions Committee   She believes that a Realtor is more than just houses and should get involved with local boards and with community outreach   Shelby is not only a member of WMAR she is also a member of the Scottsdale Association of Realtors and ARMLS  

?Shelby and her husband who is a Wildland Firefighter with the US Forest Service married in October of 2016   They have a beautiful son named Jackson who was born on September 13th 2017

?Reviews from past clients on Zillow & Realtor com have said that Shelby is patient friendly easy to work with knowledgeable professional efficient energetic makes the Real Estate process smooth and stress free and has local knowledge

?When Shelby is not at work you can find her in the woods with her family hunting fishing or hiking and enjoying this beautiful place she calls home

Navajo County, AZ Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$597,372
Avg. Listing Price
From Shelby's portfolio
3.1 / 2.4
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
1,966 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
616
Active Listings
Current inventory

Navajo County, Arizona presents one of the most geographically diverse and culturally rich real estate landscapes in the Southwest, spanning over 9,950 square miles from the high desert plateaus near Flagstaff to the dramatic canyons and mesas that define much of northeastern Arizona. This vast territory encompasses everything from vacation retreats in Show Low and Pinetop-Lakeside to rural ranch properties near Holbrook and Window Rock, creating a market that defies simple categorization.

With 386 total actively licensed agents serving this expansive region, the real estate professional density reflects both the county's geographic challenges and its diverse property types. What's particularly noteworthy is that all 386 agents maintain current email contact information, indicating a market that has fully embraced digital communication despite serving many remote and traditional communities across the Navajo Nation and beyond.

Major Navajo County, Arizona Real Estate Markets

The White Mountain region, anchored by Show Low, Pinetop-Lakeside, and Snowflake, drives much of Navajo County's recreational and second-home market activity. These higher-elevation communities attract buyers seeking cooler temperatures and mountain lifestyle amenities, with properties ranging from modest cabins to luxury mountain estates. The region's proximity to outdoor recreation and its appeal as a Phoenix escape destination creates consistent demand despite seasonal fluctuations.

Holbrook serves as the county's primary commercial and agricultural hub, offering a different market dynamic focused on working ranches, historic properties, and affordable family homes. Meanwhile, the eastern portions of the county, including areas within the Navajo Nation, present unique opportunities in rural and culturally significant properties, though these markets operate under different regulations and cultural considerations that require specialized local knowledge.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Navajo County's real estate market operates across multiple climate zones and elevation changes of over 4,000 feet, creating distinct micro-markets with vastly different property values, buyer demographics, and seasonal patterns. Properties in the high country around Show Low may appreciate differently than desert properties near Winslow, while ranch land values fluctuate based on water rights, grazing permits, and proximity to major transportation corridors like Interstate 40.

The county's substantial Native American land holdings add another layer of complexity, as these areas influence surrounding property values and development patterns while operating under tribal jurisdiction. Additionally, the region's role as a corridor between major metropolitan areas creates opportunities for commercial and investment properties, particularly around transportation hubs and tourist destinations along historic Route 66.

Why Businesses Need Navajo County, Arizona Agent Contact Data

Real estate service providers, from mortgage lenders to property management companies, require direct access to Navajo County's 386 agents to effectively serve this geographically challenging market. The county's vast distances and diverse property types mean that local agent relationships are crucial for everything from appraisal services to specialized insurance products for high-elevation homes or ranch properties.

Title companies, home inspection services, and construction contractors particularly benefit from comprehensive agent contact databases, as referral relationships drive much of the business in smaller communities like Eager, Taylor, and Joseph City. With all agents maintaining current email addresses, service providers can efficiently communicate seasonal opportunities, regulatory updates, and specialized services across this expansive and culturally diverse market.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/7/2026, Shelby Teel has 5 properties for sale in Pinetop and surrounding areas.

$460,000

Listed 2025-09-10

103 County Road 3167
Vernon, AZ  85940

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.0
Sq Ft: 1,600
Lot: 315,810 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$980,000

Listed 2025-11-13

1281 W Snow Creek Trl
Show Low, AZ  85901

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,800
Lot: 19,166 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$1,200,000

Listed 2025-11-07

7510 Geronimo Rd
Pinetop, AZ  85935

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 2,700
Lot: 21,780 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$450,000

Listed 2025-11-28

2407 Northwind Dr Unit 1
Pinetop, AZ  85935

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,790
Lot: 871 sf
Condos Map
View Full Details

$850,000

Listed 2025-05-02

7918 Lakewood Dr
Pinetop, AZ  85935

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 2,522
Lot: 19,602 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Shelby Teel currently has no rental properties available in Pinetop and surrounding areas. Check back later.