```
Shelley A Cottrell

Shelley A Cottrell
Real Estate Agent (Salesperson)
Pataskala OH

Salesperson (OH: 2007001918)

19 years experience

REALTOR® 4 Active Listings Serves Licking County, OH
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services - Metro Columbus

Office Website
Office Address
190 E Broad St
Pataskala, OH  43062-7104
(Licking County)
Office Phone
614-240-7400
Office Fax
Mobile
614-579-4635
Email
shel***@*************.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Bexley: OH Columbus: OH

About Shelley Cottrell

Shelley Cottrell is a highly regarded real estate agent with a proven track record in Columbus and its surrounding areas. Since 2007, she has consistently ranked among the top 1% of individual agents, adeptly guiding both buyers and sellers through the complexities of real estate transactions.

Her commitment to providing a seamless and enjoyable moving experience is evident in her personalized approach. Shelley excels at understanding the unique needs of each client, allowing her to develop tailored strategies that effectively meet their objectives. With her ability to foster trust and open communication, Shelley Cottrell is dedicated to making a significant impact in every transaction she undertakes.

Licking County, OH Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$467,686
Avg. Listing Price
From Shelley's portfolio
3.4 / 2.4
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,082 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
519
Active Listings
Current inventory

Licking County, Ohio presents a fascinating real estate landscape that bridges the gap between Columbus metropolitan expansion and rural Appalachian foothills. With Newark as its county seat and largest city, this central Ohio market has experienced steady growth driven by its strategic location along major transportation corridors and proximity to the state capital. The county's diverse geography, from the rolling hills around Granville to the industrial corridors of Heath, creates distinct micromarkets that require specialized local expertise.

The real estate ecosystem here is supported by 1,738 actively licensed agents, all of whom maintain current email contact information, reflecting a professionally engaged agent community. This robust agent network serves everything from historic properties in charming Granville to new construction developments in rapidly expanding suburbs like Pataskala and Johnstown, where Columbus commuters increasingly seek affordable alternatives to Franklin County's rising home prices.

Major Licking County, Ohio Real Estate Markets

Newark dominates the county's real estate activity as both the population center and economic hub, featuring a mix of historic downtown properties, established neighborhoods, and growing suburban developments. The city's revitalization efforts around the courthouse square have sparked renewed interest in urban living, while areas like Heath benefit from proximity to major employers including the massive Amazon fulfillment center. Granville stands apart as a premium market, with its connection to Denison University creating steady demand for both student housing and upscale family homes.

The western communities of Pataskala, Johnstown, and parts of Reynoldsburg represent the county's fastest-growing segments, as Columbus's suburban sprawl crosses county lines. These areas attract first-time homebuyers and families seeking newer construction at more accessible price points than similar properties in Franklin County. Meanwhile, rural townships like Hartford and Washington maintain their agricultural character while experiencing selective development pressure along major routes.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Licking County's real estate market operates with surprising independence from Columbus trends, despite the geographic proximity. Local factors like the presence of major employers, the county's role as a logistics hub due to its central location, and seasonal tourism around attractions like the Newark Earthworks create unique demand patterns. The market benefits from relatively stable pricing compared to more volatile urban markets, making it attractive for both investors and residents seeking long-term stability.

What surprises many observers is how the county's topography creates distinct pricing tiers and buyer preferences. Properties in the flatter, more developed western sections command different premiums than homes nestled in the eastern hills, while proximity to recreational amenities like Buckeye Lake influences seasonal market dynamics. This geographic complexity means successful real estate professionals must understand hyperlocal conditions across multiple distinct submarkets.

Why Businesses Need Licking County, Ohio Agent Contact Data

For mortgage lenders, insurance companies, and real estate service providers, accessing Licking County's complete agent database offers immediate connection to professionals managing diverse property types across multiple price segments. These 1,738 licensed agents represent direct pathways to active buyers and sellers in markets ranging from rural acreage to suburban developments, making them invaluable partners for businesses seeking to establish or expand their presence in central Ohio.

The universal email accessibility of these agents enables efficient digital marketing campaigns and relationship building efforts. Given the county's position as a growth market for Columbus-area expansion, businesses that establish early relationships with local agents position themselves advantageously as transaction volumes continue increasing in this strategically located and economically diverse market.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/17/2026, Shelley Cottrell has 4 properties for sale in Pataskala and surrounding areas.

$349,000

Listed 2026-01-18

423 Saint Clair Ave
Columbus, OH  43203

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,903
Lot: 3,920 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$425,000

Listed 2026-01-31

7507 Lismore Dr
Reynoldsburg, OH  43068

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 2,694
Lot: 10,454 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$273,900

Listed 2025-12-22

735 Reinhard Ave
Columbus, OH  43206

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 1.5
Sq Ft: 1,371
Lot: 4,792 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$2,399,000

Listed 2025-10-26

19533 State Route 104
Circleville, OH  43113

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 3,322
Lot: 1,205,741 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Shelley Cottrell currently has no rental properties available in Pataskala and surrounding areas. Check back later.