```
Shelton Scaife

Shelton Scaife
Real Estate Agent (Broker Sales)
Fleming Island FL

Broker Sales (FL: 3023452)

26 years experience

REALTOR® 2 Active Listings Serves Clay County, FL
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty

Office Website
Office Address
4371 Us Hwy 17 Ste 101
Fleming Island, FL  32003
(Clay County)
Office Phone
904-269-7117
Office Fax
904-264-5445
Mobile
904-591-7722
Email
shel*********@***.com
Show Email for $5

Service Areas

Green Cove Springs: FL Penney Farms: FL Asbury Lake: FL Lakeside: FL Oakleaf Plantation: FL Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace: FL Orange Park: FL World Golf Village: FL Jacksonville: FL Neptune Beach: FL Atlantic Beach: FL Fleming Island: FL Doctors Inlet: FL Middleburg: FL St. Augustine: FL

About Shelton Scaife

**Shelton Caife: Real Estate Professional**

Shelton Caife stands out in the real estate industry through a client-centric approach that prioritizes the unique needs of each individual. From the initial interaction, Shelton and his team focus entirely on delivering a seamless and rewarding real estate experience. Their commitment is to ensure that clients achieve the positive outcomes they expect and deserve.

With extensive local expertise, Shelton is readily available to assist clients throughout the buying and selling process. His team has a long history of helping both buyers and sellers, emphasizing the importance of listening to clients' needs. Understanding that the ideal home must align with the perfect setting, they work closely with clients to identify options that suit their lifestyles and preferences.

When it comes to making offers, Shelton employs strong negotiation skills and a deep understanding of best practices to secure the most favorable results for his clients. For those looking to sell their homes, Shelton has curated a list of essential questions to consider when selecting a real estate agent, which he is happy to share upon request.

Affiliated with Coldwell Banker, one of the largest national brokerages, Shelton's team effectively positions properties to attract potential buyers. They take pride in their expertise across various property types, including new constructions, historical homes, and everything in between.

**Specialty Services:**
- New Construction and Custom Home Building
- Residential Listings and Sales (Ranked in the Top 5% of Realtors in the U.S.)
- First-Time Buyers, Military Buyers, and Sellers
- Relocation Expert and Certified USAA and NFCU Preferred Agent
- Waterfront Properties, including Riverfront, Oceanfront, and Intracoastal
- Property Management Services
- Income-Producing and Commercial Investment Properties

Shelton, a native of Jacksonville, Florida, is well-acquainted with the Northeast Florida market. He is a top-selling agent known for his ability to achieve optimal results for clients.

**Business Philosophy:**
Shelton believes in prioritizing customer needs daily. He is committed to nurturing relationships and fostering trust, confident that dedication will yield positive results.

**Awards and Recognition:**
Shelton values referrals from satisfied clients as the highest form of recognition. His accolades include:
- 2016: Listed in the Top 25 Agents in Northeast Florida by the Jacksonville Business Journal
- International President's Circle and Top Individual Agent in Clay County (2012-2015)

**Credentials:**
- CNAS, CNMS, CNRS
- Member of NAR, NEFAR, and FAR
- Broker Associate

**Areas of Expertise:**
- Covering Northeast Florida, including Duval, Clay, St. Johns, and Nassau Counties
- Specializing in Military Families and Corporate Relocation
- New Home Specialist and Buyer Representation

Shelton is also certified in various military affinity groups, including CNMS and CRMS, and is a USA Cares Military Specialist. He is dedicated to being a reliable local resource for clients throughout the entire real estate process and beyond.

Clay County, FL Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$411,356
Avg. Listing Price
From Shelton's portfolio
3.7 / 2.6
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,088 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
1500
Active Listings
Current inventory

Clay County, Florida presents a compelling real estate landscape that reflects the broader growth patterns of Northeast Florida while maintaining its own distinct character. Located just south of Jacksonville and straddling the St. Johns River, this county has experienced remarkable residential expansion as buyers seek more affordable alternatives to Duval County's higher-priced markets. The area's appeal stems from its combination of suburban convenience, natural amenities, and proximity to major employment centers.

What makes Clay County particularly interesting is its transformation from a largely rural county to one of Florida's fastest-growing suburban markets. With 3,016 actively licensed real estate agents serving the area, the market demonstrates robust professional activity that supports both residential sales and commercial development. The fact that all 3,016 agents maintain email contact information reflects the tech-savvy, digitally connected nature of today's real estate professionals in this evolving market.

Major Clay County, Florida Real Estate Markets

Orange Park serves as the county's commercial and residential hub, offering established neighborhoods alongside new construction developments. The city's proximity to Naval Air Station Jacksonville and major healthcare systems drives consistent demand for housing across various price points. Fleming Island represents the county's upscale residential market, featuring waterfront communities, golf course developments, and luxury subdivisions that attract buyers from throughout the Jacksonville metropolitan area.

Green Cove Springs, the county seat, combines historic charm with modern growth, while Middleburg and Keystone Heights offer more rural residential options that appeal to buyers seeking larger lots and a quieter lifestyle. The diversity of these markets creates opportunities for real estate professionals to specialize in everything from first-time homebuyer programs to luxury waterfront properties, explaining the substantial number of active agents serving the region.

Market Dynamics and Geographic Complexity

Clay County's real estate market operates across multiple micro-markets, each influenced by different factors including school district boundaries, proximity to water features, and accessibility to major highways like Interstate 295 and US Highway 17. The county's geography, with the St. Johns River creating natural boundaries and development corridors, requires agents to understand highly localized market conditions and pricing dynamics that can vary significantly within just a few miles.

Seasonal migration patterns, military relocations, and the spillover effect from Jacksonville's growth create year-round transaction activity that differs from many other Florida markets. This complexity demands sophisticated market knowledge and explains why the county supports such a large number of real estate professionals who must stay current on everything from flood zone regulations to new construction communities and resale inventory fluctuations.

Why Businesses Need Clay County, Florida Agent Contact Data

Companies serving the real estate industry can leverage Clay County's comprehensive agent database to reach professionals handling diverse transaction types across multiple price ranges and property categories. With all 3,016 agents maintaining current email addresses, businesses can efficiently target mortgage lenders, home inspectors, insurance providers, and construction services to agents actively working in specific submarkets or specializing in particular client segments.

The concentrated nature of Clay County's agent population creates opportunities for service providers to build meaningful business relationships through targeted outreach and market-specific offerings. Whether introducing new technology platforms, financial services, or professional development opportunities, having direct access to the complete agent network enables businesses to establish presence in a growing market where real estate professionals are actively seeking resources to serve their expanding client base.

Current Property Listings

As of 2/13/2026, Shelton Scaife has 2 properties for sale in Fleming Island and surrounding areas.

$499,000

Listed 2026-01-23

36231 Pitch Ln
Hilliard, FL  32046

Beds: 4.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 2,600
Lot: 44,431 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$725,000

Listed 2025-09-25

2111 Autumn Cove Cir
Fleming Island, FL  32003

Beds: 5.0
Baths: 5.0
Sq Ft: 4,182
Lot: 11,761 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

As of 2/13/2026, Shelton Scaife has the following rental properties available in Fleming Island and surrounding areas.

$2,000

Listed 2026-01-01

75510 Harvester St
Yulee, FL  32097

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.5
Sq Ft: 1,332
Lot: 3,049 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

$1,995

Listed 2026-01-01

2215 Gabriel Dr
Orange Park, FL  32073

Beds: 3.0
Baths: 2.0
Sq Ft: 1,521
Single Family Map
View Full Details