Susan Cincotta

Susan Cincotta
Real Estate Agent (Individual Broker)
Shelter Island NY

Individual Broker (NY: 35CI0954281)

REALTOR® 1 Active Listings Serves Suffolk County, NY
View on Realtor.com

Contact Information

Brokerage
Susan C Cincotta Realtor
Office Address
Po Box 143
Shelter Island, NY  11964
(Suffolk County)
Office Phone
631-514-9891
Office Fax
Mobile
631-749-1155
Email
susancincotta@gmail.com
Website

Service Areas

Shelter Island: NY Shelter Island Heights: NY Dering Harbor: NY Noyack: NY Northwest Harbor: NY Wainscott: NY Sag Harbor: NY Bridgehampton: NY North Haven: NY Springs: NY Amagansett: NY East Hampton: NY East Hampton North: NY Sagaponack: NY Greenport West: NY Greenport: NY Napeague: NY North Sea: NY Southampton: NY Shinnecock Hills: NY Tuckahoe: NY Water Mill: NY Montauk: NY Orient: NY East Marion: NY Mattituck: NY Cutchogue: NY Peconic: NY Southold: NY

About Susan Cincotta

**Susan C. Cincotta, CBR, RSSR**
**Real Estate Broker**

With a distinguished career in real estate spanning over four decades, Susan Cincotta has established herself as a leading figure in the East End market, particularly on Shelter Island, where she has strong community ties. As a seasoned professional, she has consistently achieved recognition for her outstanding performance, including being named the Top Producer at Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty from 2010 to 2020. Her accolades include being the East End 2nd Place LIBOR Top Producer in 2013, as well as securing multiple first and second place finishes in both office listings and production from 2011 to 2018.

Susan’s expertise is underscored by her certifications as a Certified Buyer Representative and her specialized training in short sales. Her comprehensive understanding of the real estate landscape is complemented by her early career in the construction trade, where she served as a property manager and general contractor, even building her own home. This foundational experience has equipped her with a unique perspective on property sales and management.

Before transitioning to real estate, Susan worked in theatrical publishing within the motion picture industry, focusing on advertising and photography. Her background as an actress has not only fueled her passion for sales but also continues to influence her involvement in the arts, as she actively participates in local theater and coaches student actors at Shelter Island School.

In addition to her professional endeavors, Susan has made significant contributions to her community. She has served as a board member and past president of the Shelter Island Chamber of Commerce and has been involved with the Shelter Island Players. Her commitment to community service is evident through her various volunteer roles within local churches and organizations.

As the owner and broker of Susan C. Cincotta Real Estate, she remains dedicated to providing exceptional service and expertise to her clients, ensuring a seamless experience in buying or selling properties on the East End.

Suffolk County, NY Real Estate Market Analysis (Single Family Homes)

$2,260,302
Avg. Listing Price
From Susan's portfolio
4.0 / 3.1
Avg. Beds/Baths
Typical property size
2,624 sf
Avg. Square Footage
Interior living space
4211
Active Listings
Current inventory

If you need to reach actively licensed real estate agents working across Long Island's largest county, this list was built for you. Mortgage lenders, title companies, PropTech platforms, insurance brokers, continuing education providers, and sales recruiters all rely on targeted agent data to drive outreach campaigns that actually convert. Rather than wasting budget on statewide blasts that dilute your message, this list puts your offer directly in front of the professionals closing deals in Suffolk County right now.

When you buy Suffolk County real estate agent email list data from a proven source, you get more than a spreadsheet of names. You get a verified, segmented contact file covering {{AGENT_COUNT}} actively licensed agents with confirmed email addresses, plus {{CELL_COUNT}} agents who also have cell phone numbers on file — giving you multiple channels to work with from a single purchase.

Why Buy a Suffolk County Real Estate Agent Email List From Dr Bill

Every record in this list is sourced directly from the New York Department of State licensing database, so you are never buying guesswork or scraped web data. New emails are added weekly, the full list is cleaned monthly to remove bounces and bad addresses, and the entire database is rebuilt from scratch bi-annually to eliminate stale contacts. The result is a 96% deliverability guarantee that cheap list vendors simply cannot match because they are not doing the maintenance work behind the scenes.

Dr Bill has been in the data business since 2005 and has sold over 31,000 lists to clients who depend on accuracy to protect their sender reputation and campaign ROI. Whether you are uploading contacts into a cold-email platform like Zap Contact at zapcontact.com or syncing to your CRM, clean data is the difference between a campaign that lands and one that destroys your domain health. Do not gamble on a discount list when your deliverability is on the line.

How to Use This Suffolk County Agent List

Email outreach is the obvious starting point, and this list is formatted for immediate import into cold-email platforms including Zap Contact, which is purpose-built for compliant, high-volume agent prospecting. You can also use the mailing addresses for direct mail drops, leverage cell phone numbers for SMS or ringless voicemail campaigns, and upload the file to LinkedIn or Facebook for matched-audience ad targeting that reinforces your email sequence.

The list ships segmented by broker versus sales agent designation, so you can craft separate messaging for principals who make purchasing decisions versus agents who influence referrals. Filter further by city or zip code to personalize subject lines and offers down to the neighborhood level.

Why Suffolk County, New York Agent Data Matters

Suffolk County stretches from Huntington and Babylon in the west through Islip, Brookhaven, Riverhead, and out to the Hamptons and the North Fork. Each market has its own agent community with distinct volume, specialization, and business needs. Targeting all {{AGENT_COUNT}} agents in the county as a unified audience gives you far better engagement than pulling Suffolk contacts out of a generic New York State file where your message competes with noise from every other market in the state.

No other vendor offers this data segmented down to the zip code level within Suffolk County. That granularity lets you run hyper-local campaigns for a specific town, zip, or corridor rather than paying for coverage you will never use. Whether you need every agent in 11901 or everyone licensed in the Hamptons zip codes, this list delivers the precision that regional and national marketers cannot get anywhere else.

Current Property Listings

As of 6/27/2026, Susan Cincotta has 1 property for sale in Shelter Island and surrounding areas.

$4,800,000

Listed 2026-06-02

90 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island, NY  11964

Beds: 5.0
Baths: 3.5
Sq Ft: 3,325
Lot: 48,787 sf
Single Family Map
View Full Details

Current Property Rentals

Susan Cincotta currently has no rental properties available in Shelter Island and surrounding areas. Check back later.